Skip to content 
Overdetention, the act of keeping incarcerated people in custody past their legally required release dates, has become a serious problem in Louisiana’s correctional system. This systemic failure not only infringes upon the constitutional rights of detainees but also highlights severe administrative inefficiencies and mismanagement. Advocacy groups, such as the Promise of Justice Initiative and the MacArthur Justice Center, alongside affected individuals, have brought this issue to the forefront, leading to a federal investigation by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ). The DOJ’s findings revealed widespread over detention, prompting a lawsuit against the state of Louisiana. This issue raises critical questions about justice, liberty, and the need for systemic reform in the administration of the state’s prison system.
The DOJ Files A Lawsuit
The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has filed a federal lawsuit against the State of Louisiana and its Department of Public Safety and Corrections (LDOC) for systematically incarcerating individuals beyond their legally determined release dates, violating the 14th Amendment. The lawsuit asserts that LDOC’s practices infringe on the constitutional right to liberty, causing individuals to remain detained for weeks or months after completing their sentences. This over detention, according to Assistant Attorney General Kristen Clarke, undermines public confidence in the justice system and disregards lawful court orders.
A Criminal Complaint Was Brought Forward
Advocacy groups, legal organizations, and affected individuals brought the criminal complaint about over detention in Louisiana’s correctional system to the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ). By highlighting systemic issues of prolonged incarceration beyond court-mandated release dates, they drew attention to the severity of the problem.
Prominent among these organizations is the Promise of Justice Initiative, an advocacy group dedicated to criminal justice reform, and the Roderick and Solange MacArthur Justice Center, which actively represents individuals impacted by over detention in legal challenges.
The Organization Has Criticized The Corrections Facilities
These organizations have long criticized Louisiana’s Department of Public Safety and Corrections for its “deliberate indifference” to the problem of over detention. For years, they actively documented cases of inmates being held weeks or even months beyond their release dates. Subsequently, they compiled evidence of these systemic failures and presented their findings to federal authorities.
The MacArthur Justice Center has also spearheaded lawsuits against state officials, arguing that over detention violates the constitutional right to liberty under the 14th Amendment.
Inmates And Their Families Have Also Raised Their Voices
Individual complaints from affected inmates and their families also played a crucial role in sparking the DOJ investigation. Many detainees who remained in custody after completing their sentences shared harrowing accounts of their prolonged imprisonment. Their personal stories, coupled with data revealing that over a quarter of inmates experienced detention beyond their release dates within a four-month period, vividly highlight the scale and severity of the problem.
The DOJ Decided To Investigation
The DOJ’s investigation, initiated by its Civil Rights Division in collaboration with U.S. Attorneys’ Offices across Louisiana, was built on these complaints. It involved years of research and analysis to uncover patterns of systemic neglect and administrative inefficiency within Louisiana’s corrections system. The evidence collected led to the DOJ filing a lawsuit against the state, citing repeated violations of constitutional rights.
A Report Was Released
Louisiana’s prison system has faced scrutiny for holding inmates beyond their legally mandated release dates, a practice that has resulted in significant human rights violations and financial costs. Investigations revealed that between January and April 2022, the Louisiana Department of Corrections (LDOC) detained approximately 26.8% of individuals beyond their scheduled release dates. Notably, among those over detained, 24% remained in custody for at least an additional 90 days, with some cases extending even longer. This systemic failure is not a recent development but has persisted for years despite repeated warnings from legal advocates and federal authorities.
The Financial Impact Due To Over Detention
The financial impact of over detention in Louisiana is staggering. During the same four-month period in 2022, the state spent an estimated $850,000 paying parish jails to house inmates who should have already been released. This significant expenditure further underscores the costly impact of overdetention.
This expenditure represents not only a misuse of public funds but also a stark indication of inefficiencies in the state’s corrections and judicial systems. These costs are borne by taxpayers and detract from resources that could be allocated to rehabilitation programs, infrastructure improvements, or other critical services.
What Is Over Detention?
Over detention occurs when individuals in custody are held beyond their legally mandated release dates. This practice violates fundamental human rights, including the right to liberty, as well as constitutional protections against unlawful imprisonment. Over detention can extend from a few days to several months and often results from administrative inefficiencies, mismanagement, or systemic failures within correctional facilities and judicial systems.
What Causes Over Detention?
The causes of over detention are varied. A significant factor is poor communication and coordination among courts, prisons, and other authorities. For example, delays in processing release orders, updating inmate records, or transferring critical documents can result in individuals remaining incarcerated unnecessarily. In some cases, a lack of resources, such as technology or adequately trained personnel, exacerbates the problem, leading to a reliance on outdated systems that fail to ensure timely releases.
Can Lead To Prolonged Hardships
The consequences of over detention are severe and far-reaching. For the individuals affected, prolonged incarceration can lead to psychological trauma, disrupted family relationships, loss of employment, and other social and economic hardships.
These impacts intensify the injustice of losing freedom even after serving a court-mandated sentence. Furthermore, from a broader perspective, overdetention erodes public trust in the legal and correctional systems by undermining the principles of fairness and accountability that the justice system is meant to uphold.
It’s Also Unnecessary On Taxpayers
Moreover, over detention imposes unnecessary costs on taxpayers. Correctional facilities often incur significant expenses housing inmates who should no longer be in custody. This mismanagement diverts funds from other critical public services and further strains the already overburdened criminal justice system.
Addressing over detention requires systemic reform. Solutions include implementing modernized record-keeping systems, enhancing communication between agencies, and establishing accountability measures to ensure compliance with release protocols. Training personnel and allocating sufficient resources are also crucial in preventing administrative errors that lead to prolonged incarceration.
How It Violates The 14th Amendment?
Over detention directly violates the 14th Amendment of the United States Constitution, which guarantees due process and equal protection under the law. The 14th Amendment fundamentally protects individuals from being deprived of life, liberty, or property without proper legal justification. When the government holds individuals in custody beyond their legally determined release dates, it directly infringes on their right to liberty without due process, clearly breaching constitutional protections.
Violated The Due Process Clause
The Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment ensures that individuals cannot be subjected to arbitrary or unlawful actions by the state. Over detention exemplifies such arbitrary state action, as it extends incarceration beyond the period lawfully imposed by a court. A person who has completed their sentence has satisfied the terms of their punishment as dictated by the justice system. Holding them any longer constitutes an unlawful deprivation of freedom, as there is no legal basis to justify their continued imprisonment. This not only strips individuals of their right to liberty but also disregards the principle of fairness that is foundational to the rule of law.
Threatens The Equal Protection Clause
Over detention also undermines the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment. In many cases, the individuals most affected by over detention belong to marginalized communities, including those who lack access to adequate legal resources or are otherwise vulnerable to systemic inequities. This creates a disparate impact, as certain groups disproportionately experience violations of their constitutional rights. Such inequality contradicts the amendment’s promise of equal treatment under the law.
Distrust Grows Within The Community
Furthermore, overdetention actively erodes public trust in the legal system, which relies on the principle that the government must consistently act within the bounds of the law. By violating the constitutional rights of individuals through extended incarceration, the state undermines its legitimacy and the public’s confidence in its ability to administer justice fairly.
How The Governor Feels
In a joint statement with Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill, the governor acknowledged the allegations while simultaneously defending the state’s efforts to address the issues. Governor Landry emphasized that the state has made attempts to improve its correctional system, though he noted that progress requires time and resources, factors often constrained by budgetary and operational challenges.
Governor Landry, however, has argued that while the problem is serious, the state has not been idle. He pointed to recent measures aimed at enhancing coordination between courts and correctional facilities and improving record-keeping systems. Still, critics contend that these efforts have fallen short of addressing the root causes of over detention.
Governor Landry’s statement also hinted at broader frustrations with federal oversight, suggesting that while federal intervention might highlight shortcomings, it does not account for the complexities of managing a vast and underfunded correctional system. He urged for collaborative solutions rather than punitive measures, expressing hope that the lawsuit could lead to constructive dialogue and reforms rather than escalating legal conflict.
The DOJ Is Seeking Improvement
The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) is seeking significant reforms in Louisiana’s correctional system through its lawsuit against the state and the Department of Public Safety and Corrections. The primary goal is to address the systemic overdetention of inmates, a practice the DOJ argues violates the 14th Amendment’s guarantee of liberty. The lawsuit does not seek monetary damages but instead calls for injunctive relief—court-ordered measures designed to rectify the deficiencies identified during the DOJ’s multi-year investigation.
Create A Better System
Specifically, the DOJ aims to compel Louisiana to develop and implement a robust, modernized system for managing inmate release dates. This includes establishing streamlined communication channels between courts, jails, and prisons to ensure timely sharing of sentencing and release information. The DOJ aims to address administrative inefficiencies to prevent delays that have unlawfully kept inmates detained for weeks or even months beyond their mandated release dates. Through these efforts, the DOJ seeks to uphold justice and protect constitutional rights.
Improving Accountability
Additionally, the DOJ’s proposed remedies focus on improving accountability within Louisiana’s Department of Corrections. This involves creating protocols to regularly review and audit the processes governing inmate release. By identifying and addressing lapses in real-time, the DOJ hopes to eliminate the structural issues perpetuating overdetention. Training correctional staff on these updated systems and protocols is another critical aspect of the sought reforms, ensuring that employees are equipped to manage inmate records accurately and efficiently.
Need Help? Call Us Now!
Do not forget that when you or anyone you know is facing a criminal charge, you have us, the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, by your side to help you build the best defense case for you. We will work and be in your best interest for you and we will obtain the best possible outcome that can benefit you.
Our team is here to explain your trial, guiding you through the criminal justice process with clarity and support every step of the way. If you’re navigating the complexities of criminal charges and the court system seems daunting, reach out.
Therefore, do not hesitate to call us if you find yourself or someone you know that is facing criminal charges unsure about the court system. We will work with you to give you the best type of defense that can help you solve your case. It is vital to have someone explain the result of the charge to you and guide you in the best possible way.
Here at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, our professional and knowledgeable criminal law attorneys build a defense case that suits your needs, aiming for the best possible outcome to benefit you.
At the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, we offer a free consultation at your convenience. You can schedule your appointment via Zoom, Google Meet, email, or in person. We provide comprehensive advice and information to help you achieve the best possible result in your case.
Call us now at (281) 810-9760.
Other Related Articles
Legal Implications of Unreported Inmate Deaths
DOJ Latest Report: Abuse Exposed In Texas Juvenile Detention
Louisiana’s New Law: Direct Impact On Citizens
Termination of Parental Rights and an MSA in Texas
What Assets Must Go Through Probate in Texas?
FAQs on Overdetention in Louisiana
Overdetention occurs when individuals are held in custody beyond their court-ordered release dates, violating their constitutional right to liberty.
Louisiana is facing a lawsuit for systematically incarcerating individuals past their release dates, violating the 14th Amendment and undermining public trust in the justice system.
The DOJ seeks injunctive relief to enforce systemic reforms in Louisiana’s correctional system, ensuring timely inmate releases and compliance with constitutional mandates.
Some inmates in Louisiana have been held weeks or even months past their release dates due to administrative inefficiencies and lack of coordination.
Advocacy groups, legal organizations, and affected individuals raised the issue of over detention to the DOJ, prompting the investigation and subsequent lawsuit.
