Book an appointment using SetMore

Why mediation may not be appropriate in your divorce from an abusive spouse

If you are a consistent reader of the blog posts from the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, PLLC, then you know that your attorneys are big fans of mediation. Mediation is when two parties to a legal case can attend a formal negotiation session using a mediator to coordinate and communicate settlement offers. The purpose of mediation is to settle any outstanding issues in your case and avoid spending the time, money, and resources that it takes to go to trial. While not every divorce can be settled in mediation, the majority are.

In southeast Texas, courts in many counties mandate that you attend mediation before requesting a hearing or trial. I have even seen judges who do not believe that enough progress was made in the first mediation session, and as a result, a second was ordered. It’s amazing what getting people into a controlled environment can do for the ability of a case to settle. What may have seemed like insurmountable issues before may now seem within reach of settling?

Mediation may not be appropriate when the other party to your divorce has exerted an inappropriate level of force towards you that has led to an uneven balance of power. For instance, it may not be safe for you to attend a mediation session where your abusive spouse will also be present. While protections can be put in place to keep you and your spouse separated, there are no safeguards that can be 100% effective. Today’s blog post from the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, PLLC, will discuss why mediation may not be appropriate or effective in your divorce.

The reasons why your attorney may advise you against mediating

A condition that pretty much has to be in place before the mediation session begins is the ability of you and your spouse to communicate about the significant issues in your case. It is usual for divorcing spouses’ to have strained lines of communication and for you not to see eye to eye on every subject associated with your case. It is also customary to be skeptical of you and your spouse’s abilities to come together to settle your case, given your personal history and the circumstances associated with your case.

However, what is also expected in a divorce is having your spouse, and you progress those communication skills in mediation. While you will not be communicating with one another directly, you will be communicating your values and positions to your spouse through settlement offers and counter-offers. The mediator will help you see where your spouse is coming from and add perspective as to how to approach the offer/counter-offer.

Suppose you and your spouse are not in a position where you can be expected to develop or enhance your communication skills (even indirectly). In that case, mediation may not be a worthwhile endeavor to pursue in your divorce. This goes above and beyond any personal safety concerns regarding being physically close to your spouse.

If you have been the victim of abuse at the hands of your spouse, then they likely have some degree of physical, emotional, and relational control over you. As such, you run the risk of agreeing to settlement terms due to fear and intimidation. Your attorney should understand this and decline any invitation from your spouse’s attorney to attend a mediation session. If your judge typically mandates that mediation is attended, a motion should be filed to waive this requirement based on your particular circumstances.

Inability to discuss the issues before mediation: As a family law attorney, I can tell you that some opposing attorneys in divorce cases I have handled are tough to pin down their client’s positions on a range of subjects. My job is to identify the critical issues for you as my client and attempt to open a dialogue with the opposing attorney before attending mediation.

This is doubly true if there is abuse involved in the divorce. I would be wary to schedule mediation if I could not learn your spouse’s intentions and opinions on a wide range of subjects before the mediation begins. If their attorney did not discuss these subjects with us before mediation, I would not feel like the mediation session would be worthwhile and productive for you. In that scenario, moving forward would not be practical.

A note on joint decision making in determining rights and duties regarding your child

If your spouse has a history of abuse against you or your child, it is probably not reasonable to have him, or she be on par with you regarding the ability to make parenting decisions. Joint decision-making means that you and your spouse will need to communicate any essential parenting decisions together in hopes of resolving them together. The often-used term “co-parenting” is significant here.

Frequent contact with an abusive ex-spouse sounds like an opportunity for that spouse to continue to engage with you in the destructive behaviors that led to the breakdown of your marriage. Your child is a subject near and dear to your heart and allows your spouse to exert the control that they love to hold over you. Whereas no one approved their behavior during your marriage, if your spouse has joint decision-making as a part of your divorce decree, it could give them the impression that the judge approves of their tactics and attitudes.

Due to your spouse’s inability to conduct themselves appropriately during your marriage, I would argue against agreeing to share parental rights on a joint level. It may end up that your spouse does have a fair amount of independently held rights when it comes to your child. However, it would help if you did what you could to retain whatever autonomy over your child and yourself that you can get due to your divorce.

The Divorce Decree as it pertains to a case involving an abusive spouse- tomorrow’s blog post topic

We will conclude our series of blog posts on abuse and divorce by discussing topics related to the final orders of divorce in Texas- the Final Decree of Divorce. In the meantime, if you have any questions regarding today’s blog post or any other topic in family law, please do not hesitate to contact the attorneys with the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, PLLC. We offer free of charge consultations with one of our licensed family law attorneys six days a week. We can answer your questions and talk with you about the services we can provide to you and your family as clients of ours.

Categories

Let's Get Started Together

Fill out the form below 
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.