Skip to content 
Who Is Arthur Schubarth
Arthur “Jack” Schubarth, an 80-year-old rancher from Montana, found himself in legal trouble due to his ambitious but illicit venture involving the creation of “giant hybrid sheep”. Operating under Sun River Enterprises LLC at Schubarth Ranch, a 215-acre alternative livestock ranch in Vaughn, Montana, Schubarth embarked on a project that spanned from 2013 to 2021. His ranch primarily sold mountain sheep, goats, and various ungulates to captive hunting facilities, but it was his venture into creating a new breed of sheep that led to his downfall.
What is an alternative Ranch?
An alternative livestock ranch operates on the fringes of conventional animal husbandry, focusing on the rearing and management of non-traditional or exotic animals instead of the more common cattle, pigs, and chickens. This type of ranching is characterized by a diverse array of species, including but not limited to bison, elk, deer, ostriches, emus, and various types of game birds. The motivations behind establishing such ranches vary, ranging from conservation efforts to meet niche market demands for exotic meats, hides, and other animal products.
Alternative livestock ranching often requires specialized knowledge and skills, as the care, feeding, and breeding practices for these animals can be significantly different from those required for traditional livestock. Additionally, such operations must navigate a complex regulatory landscape, as the trade and transport of exotic species are tightly controlled under both national and international laws aimed at protecting endangered species and preventing the spread of diseases to native animal populations.
One of the appeals of alternative livestock ranching is the potential for high-value products. For example, venison from deer, bison meat, and ostrich leather can fetch premium prices in markets that value these as luxury or specialty items. Moreover, some ranches focus on breeding animals for conservation purposes, aiming to increase the populations of endangered species or to maintain genetic diversity.
What Is A Marco Polo Sheep?
The Marco Polo argali sheep, a subspecies of the argali sheep (Ovis ammon polii), is an iconic and elusive species native to the mountainous regions of Central Asia, including Kyrgyzstan. Renowned for their remarkable physical characteristics, particularly their massive size and the impressively long, spiraling horns found on males, Marco Polo sheep are among the most coveted trophies for hunters, and they play a significant role in the region’s natural heritage and biodiversity.
Adult males of this species can weigh over 300 pounds and stand tall, with their horns measuring up to 6 feet in length, making them the sheep with the largest horns in the world. These horns are not just a symbol of strength and virility but also serve as a crucial adaptation to their rugged, high-elevation habitats, assisting in foraging through snow in search of scarce vegetation during the harsh winters of the Pamir Mountains.
However, the Marco Polo sheep faces several threats, primarily from illegal hunting and habitat encroachment. Trophy hunting, while regulated in some areas, often leads to overexploitation, and the species’ desirability can lead to illegal poaching.
How Did He Create His New Hybrid Sheep?
Arthur “Jack” Schubarth’s venture into creating a new hybrid sheep species was a complex and controversial process, combining advanced reproductive technologies with a blatant disregard for legal and ethical boundaries. Specifically, his objective was to produce a sheep that combined the impressive size and distinctive horn characteristics of the Marco Polo argali with the traits of domestic sheep breeds. Moreover, this endeavor was driven by the desire to cater to a niche market in the captive hunting industry, where such unique and sizeable animals could consequently command high prices.
The Cloning Of Sheep For Hunting Sports
To initiate this process, Schubarth illicitly imported genetic material from the endangered Marco Polo argali sheep into the United States from Kyrgyzstan. Recognizing the significant challenges in breeding these wild sheep directly with domestic ones, he consequently turned to advanced biotechnological methods. Specifically, the genetic material obtained was then used to create cloned embryos in a specialized third-party laboratory. Moreover, this step was critical as it allowed for the replication of the argali’s genetic traits, which were pivotal to achieving the desired characteristics in the hybrid offspring.
With the cloned embryos ready, Schubarth employed artificial breeding techniques, specifically embryo transfer, to implant these embryos into domestic female sheep at his ranch. This method ensured that the surrogate mothers could carry the hybrid embryos to term, giving birth to animals that had the genetic makeup of the Marco Polo argali. The culmination of this process was the birth of a pure genetic male Marco Polo argali, dubbed “Montana Mountain King” (MMK), which represented the first successful step towards Schubarth’s goal.
MMK then became the cornerstone of the hybridization program. He was used to breed with other female sheep on the ranch, leading to the birth of hybrid animals. These hybrids were intended to possess the desirable traits of the Marco Polo argali, such as their size and unique horn structure, combined with the hardiness and manageability of domestic sheep.
How Did His Business Involve Illegal Infringements
Arthur “Jack” Schubarth’s venture into creating hybrid sheep involved a series of illegal infringements that ultimately led to his legal troubles. At the core of his operation was the unauthorized importation and use of genetic material from the endangered Marco Polo argali sheep. Schubarth’s business model centered around the creation of a new, larger, and more valuable sheep breed, intended primarily for captive hunting facilities.
The importation Of Sheep Parts
The first major legal breach involved the importation of argali sheep parts from Kyrgyzstan into the United States. Given the Marco Polo argali’s status as an endangered species, international regulations strictly control the trade and transport of such animals and their genetic materials. Schubarth’s importation of these materials violated not only international wildlife protection laws but also the U.S. Endangered Species Act, which aims to prevent the exploitation of endangered species.
Cloning Without Authorization
After acquiring the genetic material, Schubarth engaged in cloning processes to produce embryos, which were then implanted into domestic sheep. This advanced genetic manipulation required specialized knowledge and equipment, and the creation of cloned embryos from endangered species’ DNA without proper authorization was another significant legal violation.
Forgery Of Inspection Certificates
Moreover, Schubarth’s operation involved the movement of these hybrid animals across state lines, further compounding the legal infractions. The transportation of such animals required veterinary inspection certificates, which Schubarth and his co-conspirators forged, misleading authorities about the legality and origin of the sheep. This act of forgery and the interstate transport of illegally obtained wildlife contravened the Lacey Act, a U.S. law that prohibits the trade in illegally sourced plants and animals.
In essence, Schubarth’s business infringed upon a myriad of laws designed to protect endangered species and regulate the trade in wildlife. These laws aim to conserve biodiversity and ensure that the trade in animals and animal products does not threaten the survival of species in the wild. Schubarth’s disregard for these regulations not only endangered the Marco Polo argali population but also risked introducing diseases and genetic contamination to native wildlife populations. His pursuit of profit through the creation and sale of hybrid animals for trophy hunting exemplified a flagrant violation of both the spirit and the letter of international and domestic wildlife protection laws.
What Evidence Did The Prosecutors Bring To Court?
The conviction of Arthur “Jack” Schubarth for his illegal activities involving the creation and sale of hybrid sheep was supported by a substantial body of evidence that underscored the depth and complexity of his operation. Key pieces of evidence included:
Genetic Material and Cloning Documentation
Central to the case was the evidence of the importation of genetic material from the endangered Marco Polo argali sheep and the subsequent cloning efforts. Records from the third-party lab that Schubarth used for generating cloned embryos provided undeniable proof of his attempts to create a new breed of sheep. This documentation not only showed the procurement of genetic material but also detailed the cloning process, including payments and communications between Schubarth and the laboratory.
Veterinary Inspection Certificates
Schubarth’s operation required the movement of these hybrid animals across state lines, for which veterinary inspection certificates are mandatory. However, the investigation uncovered that many of these certificates were forged, thereby providing clear evidence of attempts to deceive regulatory authorities and bypass laws that govern the interstate transport of livestock.
Financial Records
The financial transactions associated with the sale of the hybrid sheep and their genetic material to hunting preserves and other breeders played a critical role in the case. Furthermore, these records demonstrated the profitability of Schubarth’s operation and highlighted the commercial motivation behind his illegal activities.
Testimonies and Co-conspirator Confessions
Testimonies from co-conspirators, employees, and clients provided firsthand accounts of Schubarth’s practices. Moreover, these confessions and testimonies added a human element to the evidence, thereby corroborating the details found in documents and financial records.
Physical Evidence
The presence of the hybrid sheep themselves, particularly the pivotal figure “Montana Mountain King” (MMK), served as direct evidence of the illegal breeding program. The unique characteristics of these animals, mirroring those of the Marco Polo argali, supported the genetic manipulation claims.
This comprehensive array of evidence painted a clear picture of Schubarth’s operation, thereby leaving little room for doubt regarding the illegality of his actions. Furthermore, the meticulous collection and presentation of this evidence were crucial in securing a conviction, thereby highlighting the rigorous investigative efforts required to address sophisticated wildlife crimes.
How Did He Plea In Court?
In court, Arthur “Jack” Schubarth took a significant legal step by pleading guilty to charges related to his creation and sale of hybrid sheep. His plea was specifically directed towards conspiring to violate the Lacey Act and the substantive violation of the same act. This acknowledgment of guilt was a pivotal moment in the legal proceedings, reflecting Schubarth’s admission to a range of illicit activities that underpinned his operation.
Pleading guilty to conspiring to violate the Lacey Act indicated Schubarth’s recognition of his involvement in an illegal agreement or plan with others to engage in activities prohibited by the act, which primarily pertains to the trade of wildlife, fish, and plants. This part of his plea shed light on the collaborative nature of his venture, implicating not just Schubarth but also his co-conspirators who played various roles in the scheme, from the cloning process to the sale and distribution of the hybrid animals.
Schubarth’s plea in court was a culmination of the evidence gathered against him, reflecting a concession to the overwhelming proof of his illegal activities. It also marked a turning point in the case, shifting the focus from establishing guilt to determining the consequences of his actions. In pleading guilty, Schubarth not only accepted responsibility for his conduct but also opened the door to potential leniency in sentencing, a common consideration in the U.S. legal system for defendants who cooperate with the prosecution. This plea was a critical juncture in the legal process, setting the stage for the subsequent phases of sentencing and penalty determination.
Need Help? Call Us Now!
Do not forget that when you or anyone you know is facing a criminal charge, you have us, the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, by your side to help you build the best defense case for you. We will work and be in your best interest for you and we will obtain the best possible outcome that can benefit you.
Our team is here to explain your trial, guiding you through the criminal justice process with clarity and support every step of the way. If you’re navigating the complexities of criminal charges and the court system seems daunting, reach out.
Therefore, do not hesitate to call us if you find yourself or someone you know that is facing criminal charges unsure about the court system. We will work with you to give you the best type of defense that can help you solve your case. It is vital to have someone explain the result of the charge to you and guide you in the best possible way.
Here at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, our professional and knowledgeable criminal law attorneys build a defense case that suits your needs, aiming for the best possible outcome to benefit you.
Also, here at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, you are given a free consultation at your convenience. You may choose to have your appointment via Zoom, google meet, email, or an in-person appointment; and we will provide you with as much advice and information as possible so you can have the best possible result in your case.
Call us now at (281) 810-9760.
Other Related Articles
- Estate Planning For Texas Ranch Owners: How To Protect Your Property and Legacy
- Big Cats, Bigger Message: Unveiling a Crucial PSA
- Wildlife Exploit: Valdez Illegal Animal Trade
- Unlocking the Secrets: How Service Animals Transform Lives
- Animal Obsession Leads Man To Receive Animal Cruelty Warrant
- The Battle Continues for Britney Spears’ Pets
FAQs about Arthur Schubarth
Arthur ‘Jack’ Schubarth is an 80-year-old rancher from Montana who was involved in creating hybrid sheep using genetic material from the endangered Marco Polo argali sheep. He operated under Sun River Enterprises LLC at Schubarth Ranch in Vaughn, Montana.
An alternative livestock ranch focuses on raising non-traditional or exotic animals such as bison, elk, deer, ostriches, and various game birds instead of conventional livestock like cattle, pigs, and chickens. These operations often cater to niche markets and conservation efforts.
Marco Polo argali sheep are a subspecies of the argali sheep native to the mountainous regions of Central Asia, including Kyrgyzstan. They are known for their large size and long, spiraling horns, making them highly prized by trophy hunters.
Schubarth created hybrid sheep by illegally importing genetic material from the Marco Polo argali sheep and using cloning techniques. He produced embryos that were implanted into domestic sheep, resulting in a new breed intended for sale to hunting facilities.
Schubarth faced charges under the Lacey Act, including conspiracy to violate the act and substantive violations. His charges involved the illegal importation of genetic material, cloning, creating hybrid animals, and falsifying veterinary inspection certificates.
