Skip to content 
When someone is charged with a crime in Texas, they’re thrust into a legal system full of unfamiliar terms, daunting procedures, and high-stakes decisions. One of the most critical choices a defendant must make is whether to accept a plea deal or go to trial. It’s a decision that can change the course of their life. It can impact their record, freedom, future job prospects, and even their family relationships.
Texas, like many states, processes a vast majority of criminal cases through plea bargains rather than trials. This isn’t just a matter of efficiency—it’s a reflection of how the system has evolved. Prosecutors are often overloaded, courts are backlogged, and public defenders are stretched thin. For many defendants, a plea deal offers certainty and a quicker resolution. But it also comes at a cost. This is true especially for those who may be innocent or who believe their case could be successfully argued before a jury.
So how does a Texas defendant decide between accepting a plea or going to trial? The answer is rarely simple. It depends on a web of factors. Some of these include the nature of the charges, available evidence, the defendant’s prior record, the potential sentence, and the quality of their legal representation.
What Is a Plea Deal?
A plea deal, or plea bargain, is an agreement between the defendant and the prosecutor. In this agreement, the defendant agrees to plead guilty or no contest to a charge, often a lesser charge. This is done in exchange for a lighter sentence or the dismissal of other charges. Plea deals can take different forms, but the primary goal is the same: resolve the case without going to trial.
In Texas, plea bargaining is a standard part of the criminal justice system. Courts encourage it to streamline dockets, reduce the burden on juries, and ensure predictable outcomes. Judges typically accept the terms of a plea bargain, though they are not required to. For the defendant, a plea deal means they give up their right to a trial. That includes waiving their right to cross-examine witnesses, present evidence, and appeal the verdict in most cases. In return, they often get a reduced sentence or avoid more serious charges that could carry harsher penalties.
The Allure of the Plea Deal
For many defendants, especially those facing serious charges, the prospect of a trial can be terrifying. A trial is unpredictable. Even a strong defense can fall apart under scrutiny, and juries can be swayed by emotion, prejudice, or poor presentation. The fear of receiving a maximum sentence is often enough to make a plea deal sound like a lifeline.
In misdemeanor cases, a plea deal might mean the difference between jail time and probation. In felony cases, it could determine whether someone spends years—or decades—in prison. Even innocent defendants sometimes take plea deals because the risk of going to trial feels too high. They might not trust the system to give them a fair shake. They might not have the resources to mount a strong defense. Or they might simply want to put the ordeal behind them.
What Happens at Trial?
A criminal trial is a formal process in which the state attempts to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the crime. Trials in Texas can be either bench trials, where the judge decides the case, or jury trials, where a panel of citizens renders a verdict. During a trial, the prosecution and defense present evidence, call witnesses, and make legal arguments. The defendant has the right to testify but cannot be compelled to do so. The trial culminates in a verdict of guilty or not guilty, and if convicted, the defendant will then face sentencing.
Going to trial carries both risks and potential rewards. A trial gives defendants the chance to fully argue their case, challenge the evidence, and seek a complete acquittal. But it also opens the door to a longer sentence if they’re found guilty—especially if they rejected a plea deal that included more lenient terms.
Key Factors Defendants Must Consider
Strength of the Evidence
This is perhaps the most crucial factor in deciding whether to go to trial or accept a plea. If the prosecution has strong evidence—such as surveillance footage, DNA, eyewitness testimony, or a confession—a guilty verdict at trial becomes more likely. In such cases, a plea deal can mitigate the damage.
Conversely, if the evidence is weak, circumstantial, or legally questionable, a skilled defense attorney may advise going to trial. Sometimes the state’s case falls apart under cross-examination, or the jury may doubt the credibility of witnesses.
Type and Severity of the Charges
The seriousness of the charges plays a big role in plea negotiations. Prosecutors are often more willing to offer favorable deals in low-level drug offenses, non-violent crimes, or first-time offenses. But in violent crimes, sex offenses, or cases with extensive criminal history, the prosecution may push for harsher terms or even refuse to offer a deal altogether.
Still, even in severe cases, a plea deal might reduce multiple felony charges to a single count, or allow a defendant to avoid a life sentence.
Prior Criminal Record
A clean criminal record can work in a defendant’s favor during plea negotiations. Prosecutors may offer leniency for first-time offenders or people with minor infractions. On the other hand, repeat offenders often receive fewer concessions and harsher plea terms, as prosecutors see them as higher-risk individuals.
In trial decisions, past convictions might also become relevant during sentencing if the defendant is found guilty. This risk may persuade some defendants to accept a plea, knowing the court will factor in their history if things go south.
Potential Sentencing Outcomes
Texas law is known for tough sentencing, particularly in felony cases. The state has a wide sentencing range that can significantly affect a defendant’s decision.
For example, a defendant facing a third-degree felony charge could receive anywhere from two to ten years in prison. If a plea deal offers two years in exchange for a guilty plea, many will see it as a safer option than risking the full ten-year maximum at trial. In capital cases, plea deals can even take the death penalty off the table, replacing it with life imprisonment.
The Defendant’s Personal Circumstances
Defendants must also consider how a conviction—by plea or trial—will affect their family, career, immigration status, and public reputation. A non-citizen may choose trial to avoid a conviction that could trigger deportation. Someone with a steady job or custody of children may prefer a plea that avoids jail time, even if it means having a conviction on record.
Some defendants might be in jail awaiting trial and accept a plea deal just to be released on time served, even if they believe they could win at trial. Others may refuse to plead guilty out of principle or a desire to clear their name.
Quality of Legal Representation
The outcome of any case depends heavily on the defendant’s legal counsel. Public defenders in Texas are often experienced but overworked. Private attorneys may have more time to devote but can be expensive. A good lawyer will thoroughly evaluate the case, explain the risks and benefits of each option, and help the defendant make an informed decision.
Inexperienced or under-resourced attorneys might push for a plea just to move the case along—even when the defendant has a legitimate defense. That’s why having effective representation is vital at every stage.
Why So Many Cases Don’t Go to Trial
Despite the high-profile nature of criminal trials on television and in the news, they’re actually quite rare. In Texas, as in most states, over 90 percent of criminal cases are resolved through plea bargaining. Trials are resource-intensive and time-consuming, and the justice system simply isn’t equipped to try every case.
Some critics argue that this system pressures defendants—especially the poor or marginalized—into pleading guilty even when they might not be. The fear of a harsh sentence can override the principle of innocence until proven guilty. Others defend plea bargaining as a practical necessity. It gives defendants control over the outcome, reduces jail overcrowding, and allows the courts to focus on the most serious or complex cases.
Is There a Right Answer?
There’s no universal rule for whether a defendant should accept a plea deal or go to trial. It depends on a careful weighing of all the factors, a realistic assessment of the risks, and honest communication with legal counsel.
Some defendants walk away from a plea and win their freedom in court. Others take a deal and regret it later. There are also many who accept a deal and feel relief that the ordeal is over, even if it means carrying a conviction.
What matters most is that the decision is informed—not rushed, coerced, or made out of fear. That’s why Texas attorneys are required to explain the consequences of plea agreements to their clients and ensure they are entered voluntarily.
Final Thoughts
The choice between a plea deal and a trial isn’t just a legal decision—it’s a deeply personal one that affects every part of a defendant’s life. In Texas, where criminal penalties can be severe and the justice system complex, this decision deserves careful, strategic thinking. Whether to take a plea or fight the charges in court should never be made lightly. With good counsel, thorough understanding of the facts, and a clear picture of the stakes, defendants can make the choice that best protects their future.
