How to Protect Yourself or Your Client from Denial of Judicial Recognition of Obergefell Retroactivity in Common Law Marriage

The Supreme Court’s ruling in Obergefell v. Hodges was a milestone for marriage equality, but its retroactive application, especially in cases involving common law marriage, can be complex. Ensuring common law marriage protection for both partners is crucial, as legal recognition and rights can vary depending on the specifics of the case and jurisdiction. Understanding how to navigate these legal nuances helps safeguard your rights and ensures that your relationship is properly recognized under the law.

What Is Obergefell Retroactivity in Common Law Marriage?

Obergefell retroactivity refers to the judicial recognition of same-sex relationships as marriages predating the June 26, 2015, decision. Common law marriage adds another layer of complexity, as its recognition depends on state laws and specific factual circumstances.

Common Situations Requiring Legal Action

These cases often involve individuals in same-sex relationships that existed before 2015. Disputes may arise in divorce proceedings, estate matters, or efforts to establish a common law marriage posthumously. While uncommon, these situations can have significant legal and financial implications, making preparedness critical.

Proactive Strategies to Protect Your Rights

Opt for Legal Marriage

The most straightforward way to avoid disputes related to common law marriage is to formalize your relationship with a legal marriage. Doing so eliminates ambiguity about your marital status and ensures that your rights are safeguarded under state and federal laws.

Relocate to a Common Law Marriage State

If legal marriage isn’t immediately feasible, consider moving to a state that recognizes common law marriage. States such as Texas, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, and Montana continue to acknowledge common law unions. Establishing residency in one of these jurisdictions strengthens your case. Residency requirements vary, but living in a state for at least three months and obtaining a driver’s license there can help confirm your intent to establish domicile.

Building a Strong Legal Case

Understand Civil Procedure

In court cases involving common law marriage and retroactivity, airtight jury charges are vital. These charges provide the jury with a clear framework for decision-making. Weak or poorly constructed charges can undermine your case. Learn from precedent-setting cases like Hinojosa v. Lafredo (Tex. App. 2021), which highlight effective strategies for addressing retroactivity disputes.

Steps to Create Airtight Jury Charges:

1. Consult legal precedents to frame arguments clearly.
2. Ensure charges account for all elements required to establish a common law marriage.
3. Collaborate with experienced attorneys to fine-tune legal language.

Addressing Adverse Outcomes

Despite careful preparation, unfavorable rulings may occur. If this happens, filing a writ of habeas corpus in Federal court may offer recourse. This legal tool allows individuals to assert that their constitutional rights, including due process, were violated. Consult a legal expert who understands federal litigation to guide this complex process.

Filing a Writ of Habeas Corpus:

1. Gather evidence supporting your claim of rights violations.
2. File the petition promptly, adhering to Federal court rules.
3. Work with experienced counsel to build a compelling argument.

The Importance of Preexisting Relationships

Courts scrutinize evidence of preexisting relationships to determine the validity of common law marriages. Documentation plays a crucial role in establishing these relationships. Proving cohabitation, joint financial responsibilities, and mutual agreements to be married strengthens your case.

Key Documents to Collect:

• Lease agreements or deeds showing cohabitation.
• Shared bank account statements.
• Affidavits from friends or family attesting to the relationship.
• Joint insurance policies or tax returns.

Practical Tips for Avoiding Legal Disputes

Be Proactive in Documentation

Whether pursuing common law recognition or protecting an existing marriage, thorough documentation is essential. Maintain detailed records of your relationship to reduce disputes later.

Seek Legal Guidance Early

Consult a legal expert familiar with common law marriage and Obergefell retroactivity cases. Early advice can clarify your options and help avoid missteps that weaken your case.

Stay Informed About State Laws

Laws governing common law marriage and retroactivity vary widely. Understanding the specific requirements in your state ensures you remain prepared for potential challenges.

Common Myths About Common Law Marriage

Myth: Living Together Automatically Creates a Common Law Marriage

Fact: Simply living together does not constitute a common law marriage. Most states require additional elements such as an agreement to be married and presenting yourselves as a married couple.

Myth: Common Law Marriages Are Recognised Everywhere

Fact: Only a handful of states recognize common law marriage. Ensure you understand the laws in your state before assuming legal recognition.

Conclusion

Protecting your rights in cases involving Obergefell retroactivity and common law marriage requires careful planning and legal expertise. Ensuring common law marriage protection often involves proactive measures such as formalizing your relationship through legal marriage, relocating to a jurisdiction that recognizes your rights, or gathering thorough documentation to strengthen your case. By working with skilled legal professionals, you can effectively safeguard your interests and navigate the complexities of this evolving legal landscape.

Ebook

If you want to know more about what you can do, CLICK the button below to get your FREE E-book: “16 Steps to Help You Plan & Prepare for Your Texas Divorce”

If you want to know more about how to prepare, CLICK the button below to get your FREE E-book: “13 Dirty Tricks to Watch Out For in Your Texas Divorce, and How to Counter Them” Today!”

Other Articles you may be interested in:

1. The Detailed Definition of Marriage in Texas
2. Can Common Law Marriage be Backdated / Is Obergefell Retroactive?
3. Does Texas Recognize Common Law Marriage? What You Need to Know About Legal Rights
4. Should I Hide Money from my Spouse to Get Ready for my Texas Divorce?
5. 7 Important Ways to Financially Prepare for Your Texas Divorce
6. 6 Tips – On How to Prepare for a Texas Divorce
7. What are the Steps of a Contested Texas Divorce, and How Can I Prepare for Them?
8. Can I get child support while my Texas divorce is pending?
9. 6 Mistakes that Can Destroy Your Texas Divorce Case
10. 6 things You Need to Know Before You File for Divorce in Texas
11. What living arrangements may lead a judge to conclude that you are common law married?