Skip to content 
On August 8, 2024, Texas Governor Greg Abbott signed Executive Order GA 46, which mandates state hospitals to collect and report data related to healthcare costs incurred for treating individuals who are not lawfully present in the United States.
What The Order Aims To Do
Texas Governor Greg Abbott signed Executive Order GA-46 to address the financial impact of healthcare costs for individuals who are not lawfully present in the United States. The order primarily seeks to collect comprehensive data on how these healthcare expenses burden state resources. By quantifying these costs, the state intends to build a case for federal reimbursement, arguing that these expenditures exceed Texas’s fiscal responsibility and should be covered by federal funds.
Create A System To Collect Information
The order establishes a system for collecting detailed information from hospitals, including the number of inpatient discharges, emergency room visits, and associated costs linked to undocumented individuals. This data collection aims to provide a clear picture of how these healthcare needs impact Texas’s healthcare infrastructure and budget. By analyzing this information, the state hopes to show the need for additional federal support to cover these expenses. These costs often arise from federal laws that require emergency medical treatment, regardless of a patient’s immigration status.
Created To Maintain Transparency
The executive order also aims to maintain transparency in the reporting process. It requires hospitals to inform patients that providing their immigration status is voluntary and will not impact the medical care they receive. This provision reassures patients while ensuring compliance with federal laws that protect access to emergency healthcare.
Critics Argue It Discourages Treatment
However, critics argue that the order could inadvertently discourage vulnerable populations from seeking necessary care, fearing potential repercussions despite assurances. The policy does not include mechanisms to analyze the economic contributions of undocumented individuals, which could balance the discussion by highlighting their role in the state economy. Furthermore, it lacks safeguards to prevent misuse of the collected data, raising concerns about privacy and discrimination.
When Does The Executive Order Start
Governor Greg Abbott’s Executive Order GA-46 mandates the data collection process to begin on November 1, 2024. This start date signals the launch of a structured effort to gather detailed information about healthcare costs related to treating individuals who are not lawfully present in the United States. Starting on this date, hospitals across Texas must document specific data points, such as the number of inpatient discharges, emergency room visits, and the associated expenses for undocumented patients.
A Step Into Addressing The Financial Impact
This data collection serves as a foundational step in the state’s broader objective of assessing the financial impact of providing healthcare to this demographic. Hospitals will submit the collected information to the Texas Health and Human Services Commission (HHSC) on a quarterly basis, with the first report due by March 1, 2025. This phased timeline gives both hospitals and the HHSC enough time to establish systems and procedures to meet the order’s requirements.
The implementation date of November 1, 2024, is significant because it underscores the state’s urgency in addressing perceived gaps in healthcare funding and reimbursement. By setting a clear start date, the order provides hospitals with a specific timeframe to prepare for compliance, including training staff, creating data collection protocols, and ensuring that patient communication aligns with federal laws. It also gives the HHSC time to standardize reporting formats and establish mechanisms for analyzing the data.
Critics Argue: Charity Care Covers Healthcare Cost For Immigrants
Charity care is a critical component of the healthcare system, designed to ensure that individuals who cannot afford to pay for medical services still have access to essential healthcare. It involves hospitals and healthcare providers offering medical treatment either free of charge or at significantly reduced costs to patients who meet specific financial criteria. This system is especially crucial for uninsured or underinsured individuals who might otherwise forgo necessary medical attention due to financial constraints.
Obligated To Provide Charity Care
Public and nonprofit hospitals often must provide charity care to receive federal funding or maintain their tax-exempt status. In exchange, these institutions receive financial support through mechanisms such as Medicaid Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) payments or specific federal waivers like the 1115 Medicaid waiver. These funds help offset the costs incurred by hospitals for treating uninsured patients, ensuring the financial sustainability of the care provided. For example, in Texas, federal sources provide over 64% of charity care funding, highlighting the federal government’s significant role in supporting uncompensated healthcare services.
Helps Maintain Public Health
Charity care not only serves as a safety net for vulnerable populations but also helps maintain public health by addressing the medical needs of the underserved. This system is particularly significant in emergency situations where patients are legally entitled to receive care regardless of their ability to pay. Hospitals provide charity care to fulfill their community service obligations, contributing to improved health outcomes and economic stability.
What Happens If Hospitals Don’t Comply
If Texas hospitals fail to comply with the requirements of Governor Greg Abbott’s Executive Order GA-46, they risk significant penalties, including the potential expulsion from Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP). The executive order mandates that hospitals collect and report data on inpatient discharges, emergency visits, and the costs associated with treating patients who are not lawfully present in the United States. Compliance is essential for any hospital enrolled in Medicaid or CHIP, as these programs provide critical funding streams for healthcare facilities.
Could Face Financial Repercussions
Hospitals that fail to adhere to the order’s reporting requirements could face financial repercussions. Medicaid and CHIP funding constitute a substantial portion of the budgets for many hospitals, especially those serving low-income or uninsured populations. Losing access to these programs would not only strain a hospital’s finances but could also jeopardize its ability to provide care to vulnerable communities. Additionally, noncompliance might lead to increased scrutiny or audits from the Texas Health and Human Services Commission (HHSC) or other regulatory bodies.
Could have Administrative Penalties Due To Deadline
The order also includes deadlines for submitting data, with the first report due on March 1, 2025. Hospitals are required to provide quarterly updates to HHSC and annual summaries starting January 1, 2026. Failure to meet these deadlines could result in administrative penalties or further restrictions on funding. Moreover, the reputational harm of noncompliance might deter patients from seeking care, exacerbating public health challenges.
Patients Are Not Obligated To Provide Immigration Status
Governor Greg Abbott’s Executive Order GA-46 does not require patients to disclose their immigration or citizenship status when seeking medical care, and it explicitly prohibits hospitals from pressing for this information. This rule aligns with federal regulations, particularly the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA), which guarantees that all individuals, regardless of their ability to pay or immigration status, can access emergency medical services.
EMTALA mandates that hospitals with emergency departments screen and stabilize patients without discrimination, meaning that care cannot be denied based on immigration status or any refusal to answer questions about it.
Hospitals Are To Inform Patients Its Voluntary
Hospitals are required to inform patients that providing this information is voluntary and that declining to answer will not affect the care they receive. This protection is essential to maintaining trust between healthcare providers and patients, particularly in vulnerable communities. It addresses concerns that such policies might create a chilling effect, deterring individuals from seeking necessary care due to fears of discrimination or potential immigration enforcement.
Collecting Generalize Information
Furthermore, the executive order emphasizes aggregate data collection rather than individual patient tracking. This approach reduces the risk of improper use of personal information, such as sharing it with immigration authorities. To maintain privacy, hospitals focus on reporting generalized cost data instead of obtaining or disclosing specific patient details. As a result, individual privacy remains protected.
Data Collection Is Protected From Immigration
Governor Greg Abbott’s Executive Order GA-46 includes provisions to protect patient data and prevent its misuse or sharing with immigration enforcement agencies. Hospitals must report aggregate data on healthcare costs for patients who are not lawfully present in the United States, rather than specific, identifiable information. This approach ensures the collected data cannot be traced back to individuals, which significantly reduces the risk of misuse in immigration enforcement actions.
It Is In Line With HIPPA
The focus on aggregate reporting aligns with federal privacy laws such as the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), which safeguards patients’ medical and personal information from unauthorized disclosure. By limiting the type of data reported to general cost figures rather than individual patient records, the executive order aims to comply with these legal protections while achieving its stated goal of assessing the fiscal impact on the healthcare system.
Need Help? Call Us Now!
Do not forget that when you or anyone you know is facing a criminal charge, you have us, the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, by your side to help you build the best defense case for you. We will work and be in your best interest for you and we will obtain the best possible outcome that can benefit you.
Our team is here to explain your trial, guiding you through the criminal justice process with clarity and support every step of the way. If you’re navigating the complexities of criminal charges and the court system seems daunting, reach out.
Therefore, do not hesitate to call us if you find yourself or someone you know that is facing criminal charges unsure about the court system. We will work with you to give you the best type of defense that can help you solve your case. It is vital to have someone explain the result of the charge to you and guide you in the best possible way.
Here at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, our professional and knowledgeable criminal law attorneys build a defense case that suits your needs, aiming for the best possible outcome to benefit you.
At the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, we offer a free consultation at your convenience. You can schedule your appointment via Zoom, Google Meet, email, or in person. We provide comprehensive advice and information to help you achieve the best possible result in your case.
Call us now at (281) 810-9760.
Other Related Articles
How Can Health Issues Lead to Custody Modification?
The End Of The Dead Suspect Loophole
Misappropriation And Corruption: The Surprise Mississippi Welfare Scandal
New Texas child support law seeks to hold impaired drivers accountable
FAQs: Governor Abbott’s Executive Order GA-46
Governor Abbott’s Executive Order GA-46 aims to collect data on healthcare costs for individuals not lawfully present in the U.S. The order seeks to quantify these costs and request reimbursement from the federal government.
No, patients are not required to disclose their immigration status. Hospitals must inform patients that providing this information is voluntary and will not affect their care, as mandated by federal laws like EMTALA.
The data collected under GA-46 is reported in aggregate form and does not include identifiable patient information. This approach aligns with HIPAA privacy standards to ensure sensitive data is not misused or shared with immigration enforcement.
Hospitals that fail to comply with GA-46 risk being expelled from Medicaid and CHIP programs, which could have severe financial consequences, particularly for facilities serving uninsured or low-income populations.
Data collection begins on November 1, 2024. Hospitals must submit their first report to the Texas Health and Human Services Commission (HHSC) by March 1, 2025, followed by quarterly reports and annual summaries starting January 1, 2026.
