Skip to content 
When you’re looking to combine philanthropy with income planning, two tools stand out: the Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust (CRAT) and the Charitable Remainder Unitrust (CRUT). These irrevocable trusts allow you to support charitable organizations while retaining income for yourself or other beneficiaries. The big question is: which one is better for your goals? This post explores the differences, implications, and strategic considerations of a charitable remainder annuity trust vs charitable remainder unitrust with precision.
Income Distribution: Fixed vs. Flexible
The first key difference between CRATs and CRUTs lies in how income is distributed.
CRAT (Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust):
- Provides a fixed dollar amount each year.
- The payment is calculated as a percentage (at least 5%) of the trust’s initial fair market value at the time of funding.
- This amount does not change regardless of how well the trust performs.
CRUT (Charitable Remainder Unitrust):
- Pays a fixed percentage (again, at least 5%) of the current fair market value of trust assets.
- This value is re-calculated annually, so distributions vary year to year based on investment performance.
In Texas, both CRATs and CRUTs must comply with federal guidelines under IRC Section 664 and are subject to the Texas Trust Code when it comes to trustee conduct and fiduciary responsibilities. CRATs appeal to those who prefer predictable income, while CRUTs are a better fit for those seeking potential growth and who can tolerate fluctuation.
Contributions and Asset Flexibility
CRAT:
- You cannot contribute more assets once the trust is funded.
- Commonly used when there is a one-time liquidity event like the sale of a business or appreciated real estate.
CRUT:
- Allows ongoing contributions.
- More suitable for those with staggered asset availability or those who want to set up a long-term giving plan that evolves over time.
In practice, CRUTs offer greater planning flexibility. For instance, if you receive rental income from Texas real estate or stock options from a tech firm in Austin, you can continue contributing those over time into a CRUT.
Tax Deduction Considerations
Both CRATs and CRUTs offer charitable income tax deductions when the trust is established, but how those deductions are calculated differs.
- The IRS uses the Section 7520 rate, the age of the beneficiaries, the trust term, and the payout rate to determine the present value of the remainder interest.
- This value is what qualifies as your charitable deduction.
For CRATs, the deduction is calculated once at the inception. For CRUTs, the ability to add assets means deductions can be recalculated as new contributions are made.
In Texas, there’s no state income tax, so all deduction benefits are on your federal return. That makes understanding the timing of the deduction even more critical if you’re looking to offset a high-income year.
Investment Growth and Risk
Investment performance impacts both trust types differently.
- CRATs are largely insulated from market performance when it comes to distributions. You receive a set amount, but that also means you won’t benefit if the market does well.
- CRUTs fluctuate based on annual asset revaluation. If the market performs strongly, your payout can increase. However, in a downturn, your payout will shrink.
So, the choice comes down to your appetite for risk. If you’re looking for financial certainty in retirement, a CRAT may be more suitable. If you’re comfortable with the ebb and flow of the market and want the chance for a growing income, a CRUT is more appropriate.
Also, in Texas, trustees must act prudently under the “prudent investor rule,” meaning investment decisions should align with the terms of the trust and beneficiaries’ needs.
Duration and Term Planning
Under IRS rules:
- Both CRATs and CRUTs must pay income either for the life of the beneficiary (or beneficiaries) or a term of up to 20 years.
- The present value of the remainder interest must be at least 10% of the initial contribution.
A CRAT’s fixed nature makes it easier to meet this 10% requirement. CRUTs require more sophisticated actuarial modeling, especially when multiple contributions are involved.
In Texas, trusts involving minors or special-needs beneficiaries are subject to court scrutiny. This means CRUTs with variable income may not be ideal unless carefully drafted with legal input.
Distribution Ordering and Taxation
Both CRATs and CRUTs distribute income in a specific IRS-mandated order:
- Ordinary income
- Capital gains
- Tax-exempt income
- Return of principal
This structure benefits those transferring appreciated assets. For example, if you own farmland near Dallas that’s appreciated significantly, you can place it in a CRUT, sell it within the trust without immediate capital gains, and receive income from the full proceeds.
CRATs function similarly but are typically better suited to a one-time asset contribution, as the gain is spread over a known distribution schedule.
Trust Termination and Charitable Payout
Once the trust term ends or the beneficiary dies:
- The remaining trust assets go to one or more designated charitable organizations.
- You can choose any 501(c)(3) organization, including local Texas-based charities or national nonprofits.
Important note: You can structure both CRATs and CRUTs to allow successor income beneficiaries (like your spouse) to continue receiving income, subject to the same payout rules.
If you’re considering this, ensure your trust document is carefully written and follows IRS guidelines to avoid disqualification and penalties.
Estate Planning and Asset Protection
From an estate planning perspective:
- Assets placed in either CRAT or CRUT are removed from your taxable estate, reducing potential estate taxes.
- Texas follows federal estate tax law, and while most estates fall below the federal threshold (currently $13.61 million per person for 2024), these trusts can be crucial for high-net-worth individuals.
Moreover, irrevocable trusts in Texas provide a level of asset protection from creditors, provided the trust wasn’t established to defraud them. This means your CRUT or CRAT can be an effective tool not just for charitable giving, but also for wealth preservation.
Real-World Application Scenarios
To bring these concepts into sharper focus, consider how CRATs and CRUTs work in different real-world scenarios:
- If you’re selling a business in Houston and expect a one-time capital gain of $2 million, a CRAT might be your best bet. It provides a consistent income stream, reduces your taxable estate, and delivers a sizable tax deduction in the year of the sale.
- If you’re a physician in San Antonio with fluctuating bonuses and a long-term plan to give to medical research, a CRUT allows you to contribute in phases, benefit from long-term tax deductions, and receive income that adjusts with market performance.
- If you own appreciated investment property in Austin and want to avoid a large capital gains tax hit, transferring the property into a CRUT can allow for a sale inside the trust, defer taxes, and create lifetime income for you and your spouse.
Each case requires a custom strategy, and the success of your plan hinges on your ability to align the trust structure with your financial goals and charitable values.
Conclusion
When it comes to charitable remainder annuity trust vs charitable remainder unitrust, the right choice hinges on your income needs, tax situation, risk tolerance, and philanthropic goals. CRATs provide stability and predictability but lack flexibility. CRUTs offer adaptability and potential income growth but carry market exposure.
Your decision should be informed by a full understanding of your financial picture, your long-term plans, and the legal and tax framework governing trusts. In Texas, while the trusts operate under federal tax law, compliance with the Texas Trust Code ensures your wishes are carried out properly and your trustees stay within their legal bounds.
Before you act, consult an estate planning attorney or a qualified financial advisor with expertise in charitable trusts. These aren’t DIY strategies—precision and proper execution matter.
Other Related Articles
- What is a Charitable Remainder Trust? Your 2025 Guide to Giving and Receiving
- How Revocable Living Trust Helps You Stay in Control of Your Legacy
- What Every Parent Should Know About What is a Revocable Living Trust
- What My Clients Wish They Knew Before Setting Up Their Living Will Vs Living Trust
- Texas Trust Options for Estate Planning: Finding the Right Fit
- Probate vs Trust Administration: Which is right for you?
- Best practices for trustees who rely on others to assist with the administration?
- What are trusts, and why are they important in estate planning?
- Is Life Insurance a Probate Asset in Texas? What You Need to Know
- Is Community Property Subject to Probate in Texas? A Comprehensive Guide
FAQs
Yes, you can name multiple income beneficiaries, such as yourself and a spouse. The trust will continue paying income based on the longest-lived beneficiary or until the set term expires.
The trustee is still required to pay the fixed annuity amount. If the trust assets are depleted, the payments must still be made, which can create risk for the remainder charity. That’s why initial funding amounts and payout rates must be carefully calculated.
Generally, no. Once the charitable beneficiary is named in an irrevocable trust, changing it requires very specific provisions. However, you can name a donor-advised fund as the remainder beneficiary to retain some flexibility.
Yes. The IRS requires the payout to be at least 5% and no more than 50% of the trust’s fair market value. Also, the trust must pass a 10% remainder interest test to qualify as a charitable remainder trust.
Yes, you can serve as trustee, though you must administer the trust in strict accordance with fiduciary duties. If you’re in Texas, this means following the prudent investor rule and ensuring annual accountings and compliance with the Texas Trust Code.
