Skip to content 
When custody becomes a topic in divorce or separation, kids often feel stuck in the middle. Some start to express where they want to live, especially around their teenage years. Parents then ask a tough question: can a 13-year-old choose which parent to live with? The answer isn’t as simple as yes or no. While courts take a teen’s voice seriously, it doesn’t mean that voice controls the final outcome. Judges consider a mix of legal rules, emotional maturity, and what’s best for the child before making that decision.
Does Age Matter in Custody Decisions?
Judges often hear from children during custody cases, especially once they reach their teens. Age alone doesn’t give a child full control, but it increases the weight of their opinion.
In most states, including Texas, courts begin considering the child’s preference at age 12. That means a 13-year-old can express a choice, and the judge may consider it seriously.
Still, the court must focus on what’s best for the child. A judge won’t automatically grant custody based on preference alone. They look at why the child made that choice and if it fits their well-being.
How Courts Hear a Child’s Preference
A child usually doesn’t testify in open court. Most states allow a private interview with the judge. This process reduces stress and protects the child from being placed in the middle of a conflict.
Some states require a formal request before this interview can happen. Others give judges the choice to request a meeting with the child. In Texas, for example, the court must meet privately with a child aged 12 or older if either parent requests it.
The judge may ask questions like:
- Why do you want to live with this parent?
- How do you feel about your current living situation?
- What’s your relationship like with each parent?
- How do you handle school, activities, and home life?
These answers help the court understand the child’s maturity and the reasons behind their preference.
Factors Judges Consider Alongside the Child’s Opinion
A 13-year-old’s voice matters, but it’s one part of a larger picture. Courts look at several factors before making a final decision.
1. Stability
Judges want to place children in homes that support structure and growth. This includes steady routines, school performance, and emotional support.
2. Parental Behavior
The judge will review each parent’s behavior. This includes their involvement, cooperation with court orders, and willingness to co-parent. A parent who badmouths the other or pressures the child may lose credibility.
3. Safety and Well-Being
If either home poses a risk—due to abuse, substance use, or neglect—the court may disregard the child’s preference, even if they want to live in that environment.
4. Sibling Relationships
Courts often try to keep siblings together unless separating them clearly benefits one child.
5. Emotional Maturity of the Child
Some 13-year-olds show insight and maturity. Others make choices based on perks or pressure. Judges can tell the difference. If a child says, “I want to live with Dad because he doesn’t make me do homework,” the judge may not give that opinion much weight.
Can a Child’s Choice Be Overruled?
Yes. Judges are not bound by the child’s preference. If the court believes the choice doesn’t match the child’s best interest, it will overrule it.
For example, if a 13-year-old wants to live with a parent who offers fewer rules or allows poor behavior, the judge may deny the request. Courts focus on what supports the child’s safety, health, and development, even if the child disagrees.
When Parents Disagree on Custody
If one parent supports the child’s choice and the other disagrees, the court steps in to resolve the matter. Both sides can present evidence, including school records, counseling reports, and witness testimony.
The judge will listen to the child’s opinion in private and then make a decision based on the evidence presented.
How to Respond When a Child Chooses the Other Parent
Hearing that your child wants to live with the other parent can be painful. Still, it’s important to stay calm and respectful. Don’t blame the child or argue with them. Doing so may damage your relationship and hurt your chances in court.
Instead:
- Ask why they feel that way
- Show understanding
- Stay involved in their life
- Focus on long-term connection, not temporary control
Courts often reward parents who act maturely during disputes and maintain focus on the child’s needs.
Can a 13-Year-Old Refuse to Visit a Parent?
If the court has already ordered a custody schedule, both parents must follow it. A 13-year-old cannot legally refuse visitation on their own. The parent with custody at the time must make the child available for visits.
If the child strongly resists, parents should document the behavior and seek legal help. Repeated refusal may justify a motion to modify custody, but don’t take matters into your own hands.
When to Request a Custody Modification
You can file a request to modify custody if you believe your child’s preference reflects a genuine change in their needs or safety.
Reasons might include:
- A child now prefers to live with you full-time and has valid reasons
- The other parent’s behavior affects the child negatively
- The child’s needs have changed as they age
Be ready to present evidence beyond just the child’s words. The court will look at the full picture before making changes.
How to Support Your Child During a Custody Decision
Even if your child seems strong, custody disputes can weigh heavily on them. Help them stay centered and supported.
- Avoid asking them to choose sides
- Keep adult issues between adults
- Encourage open communication without judgment
- Work with a counselor if needed
Your job as a parent is to reduce stress and provide stability, even during legal battles.
Final Thoughts
A 13-year-old can share their opinion about which parent they want to live with, but that alone doesn’t decide custody. Judges listen, ask questions, and weigh the full situation before making a decision. Maturity, safety, consistency, and emotional well-being guide the court—not just personal preference.
If you’re facing this situation, don’t act out of fear or frustration. Speak with a family law attorney, gather evidence, and focus on what helps your child feel supported during a time of change.
Ebook
If you want to know more about what you can do, CLICK the button below to get your FREE E-book: “Child Custody E-Book”
Other Related Articles:
- The Truth About Child Custody Cases in Texas: Debunking 10 Common Myths
- What does a business owner need to know about child custody in Texas?
- Can cannabis use affect your parenting and custody rights?
- Managing High-Conflict Custody Cases in Texas: A Step-By-Step Guide
- Evaluating Parental Fitness: Home Studies and Custody Evaluations in Texas
- How grandparents can help themselves win custody of their grandchildren
- Police officers and child custody issues
- Do you have to pay child support if you have 50/50 custody in Texas?
- If you have primary custody (custodial parent), you can still be ordered to pay child support?
- The effect of substance abuse on child custody determinations
- In Texas, is it legal for my child’s mother to keep them from me?
- Can cannabis use affect your parenting and custody rights?
- Police officers and child custody issues
- What to do When Your Child Does Not Want to Visit the Other Parent
- If you have primary custody (custodial parent), you can still be ordered to pay child support?
- When Can a Minor Child Weigh in on Custody Decisions in Texas?
- Can an 11-year-old choose which parent to live with?
Frequently Asked Questions
The ability to choose which parent to live with at the age of 12 can vary depending on the jurisdiction. It’s important to consult with a legal professional to understand the specific laws and guidelines in your area.
The age at which a child can have a say in custody decisions may differ across jurisdictions. Consulting with a family law attorney will provide you with accurate information based on the laws applicable in your area.
In Texas, according to the Texas Family Code, a child who is 12 years old or older may express their preferences regarding their living situation to the court. However, the final decision still rests with the judge, who considers the child’s opinion alongside other relevant factors.
In Texas, a 16-year-old may have a stronger ability to express their preferences to the court. However, it’s important to note that the judge will consider the child’s opinion along with other factors when making custody determinations.
