Skip to content 
When planning for future medical care, many people come across two powerful tools: the living will and the DNR, or “Do Not Resuscitate” order. Both of these documents relate to your wishes regarding life-sustaining treatment, but they serve distinct purposes and operate under different circumstances.
A living will outlines which medical treatments you want or do not want if you are unable to communicate. It can include preferences about life support, feeding tubes, and artificial hydration. On the other hand, a DNR specifically instructs medical personnel not to attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) if your heart stops or you stop breathing.
Though they may sound similar, understanding how a living will vs DNR operates within the healthcare and legal systems can help you make more informed decisions. Let’s find out how these tools differ, when they apply, and how each one fits into a larger plan for end-of-life care especially under Texas law.
- When a Living Will Applies and What It Covers
- What a DNR Covers and When It’s Used
- Legal Requirements for Each in Texas
- Differences in Scope: Living Will vs DNR
- Choosing Between a Living Will and a DNR
- The Role of Family and Healthcare Agents
- Can These Documents Be Changed or Revoked?
- What Medical Professionals Are Required to Follow
When a Living Will Applies and What It Covers
A living will, formally called a Directive to Physicians under Texas law, becomes effective only when your attending physician certifies that you have a terminal or irreversible condition and can no longer make informed healthcare decisions for yourself. It does not apply in routine medical care or while you’re still capable of expressing your preferences.
This advance directive helps ensure that your medical care aligns with your values during critical moments.
Conditions That Trigger a Living Will
Two licensed physicians must confirm both of the following before your living will can take effect:
- You are incapable of making decisions or communicating
- You are diagnosed with a terminal condition or irreversible condition as defined by Texas law
A terminal condition refers to one that is incurable and expected to result in death within six months, even with life-sustaining treatment. An irreversible condition is one that may not be immediately fatal but prevents meaningful recovery or decision-making capacity.
Medical Decisions Typically Addressed
Your living will typically outlines whether you want or do not want certain medical interventions in these scenarios. Common treatments addressed include:
- Mechanical ventilation
Whether you want a machine to take over your breathing if your lungs fail. - Artificial nutrition and hydration
Whether you wish to receive feeding through a tube or intravenous fluids when you’re unable to eat or drink naturally. - Dialysis
Used when kidneys fail to filter waste, dialysis may be continued or withheld based on your directive. - Use of antibiotics or other medications
You may specify if you want treatment for infections when you’re in an end-stage condition. - Comfort care (palliative care)
Most living wills allow for continued pain relief and comfort measures regardless of other treatment limitations.
Scope of Customization Under Texas Law
Texas gives individuals broad authority to personalize their living will to match their values and beliefs. This means you’re not restricted to an all-or-nothing approach.
You may:
- Accept all forms of treatment except artificial feeding
- Choose to allow life-sustaining treatment only for a defined period (e.g., trial period of 10 days)
- Decline all treatments except comfort-focused care
- Request that religious or ethical considerations guide decision-making in ambiguous situations
These decisions are usually documented by checking boxes or providing written instructions in the Texas Directive to Physicians form. You can also attach an addendum for further explanation.
Who Interprets the Living Will?
When the directive goes into effect, your attending physician must follow it as written. If the instructions are unclear or circumstances change, your appointed Medical Power of Attorney (if named) may provide interpretation consistent with your expressed wishes.
The healthcare team may also consult close family members, but only if your directive allows or does not explicitly prohibit it.
What Happens if You Don’t Have One?
If no living will is in place and you’re unable to communicate, decisions typically fall to your designated healthcare agent (if any), or else your family members according to Texas priority laws. Without a directive, there may be disagreements or confusion about your care preferences especially concerning life-sustaining interventions.
What a DNR Covers and When It’s Used
A DNR is much more specific. In Texas, you may complete an Out-of-Hospital DNR Order (OOH-DNR), which informs emergency medical services (EMS) and hospital staff not to administer CPR.
Situations Where a DNR Applies
A DNR does not prevent all medical treatment. It applies only to:
- Chest compressions
- Defibrillation
- Artificial respiration
- Intubation to restore breathing or heartbeat
It does not prevent:
- Oxygen administration
- Pain medication
- Bleeding control
- Comfort care
This distinction is vital. A DNR only comes into play during a cardiac or respiratory arrest. In contrast, a living will affects treatment decisions over a longer course of illness.
Legal Requirements for Each in Texas
Both the living will and the DNR require proper documentation under Texas law to be valid and enforceable.
Living Will Legal Formalities
To be valid, a Texas Directive to Physicians must be:
- Signed by you (the declarant)
- Witnessed by two qualified witnesses OR
- Notarized by a Texas notary public
Witnesses cannot be related to you, entitled to any portion of your estate, or involved in your healthcare decisions.
DNR Order Protocol
A Texas Out-of-Hospital DNR Order must be:
- Signed by the patient or legal representative
- Signed by a physician
- Clearly marked (original form or designated identification like a bracelet)
Without proper documentation, EMS is legally required to perform CPR even if verbal requests are made.
Differences in Scope: Living Will vs DNR
Understanding the distinction between a living will vs DNR helps clarify what each document controls.
| Feature | Living Will | DNR Order |
| Type of Document | Advance directive | Physician’s medical order |
| When It Applies | During terminal or irreversible condition | During cardiac or respiratory arrest |
| Scope of Treatment | Broad decisions (ventilators, feeding tubes) | Only CPR-related interventions |
| Requires Physician Signature | Not initially required | Always required |
| Emergency Medical Use | Not typically reviewed in emergency | Reviewed by EMS and hospital staff immediately |
| Duration | Until revoked or patient recovers | Until revoked or updated |
This table simplifies a crucial difference: living wills are preference-based documents, while DNRs are physician orders with legal force in emergencies.
Choosing Between a Living Will and a DNR
You don’t have to choose one over the other. In fact, many individuals opt to have both in place. They serve complementary functions.
Consider a Living Will If:
- You want to address long-term medical treatment scenarios
- You’re concerned about future loss of capacity
- You want to give general direction to your physician and family
Consider a DNR If:
- You have a terminal illness or advanced age
- You do not want CPR in the event of cardiac arrest
- You want emergency responders to know your preferences quickly
If you’re uncertain, speak with a healthcare provider familiar with Texas advance directive laws. They can help clarify how each tool works and whether both would support your end-of-life care planning.
The Role of Family and Healthcare Agents
Even if you have a living will or a DNR, your healthcare agent or next of kin may be involved in decision-making.
Healthcare Agent and Living Will
If you’ve also executed a Medical Power of Attorney (MPOA), that person can make decisions not explicitly stated in your living will. However, the living will usually takes precedence regarding specific medical directives.
Family and DNR Orders
DNRs are respected as long as the proper form is available. But if family members are unaware or object strongly in an emergency, and no form is present, medical staff may proceed with CPR.
Clear communication with your family and healthcare agent ensures that your documents are honored and followed as intended.
Can These Documents Be Changed or Revoked?
Yes. Both a living will and a DNR order can be revoked or modified.
Revoking a Living Will
You can cancel your living will at any time by:
- Tearing it up
- Signing a written revocation
- Verbally communicating revocation (if you are competent)
Let your physician and healthcare agent know if you make changes.
Revoking a DNR Order
To revoke a DNR:
- Notify the attending physician
- Physically destroy the form
- Remove identification tags like bracelets
After revocation, the physician may update your medical record and issue a different care directive if needed.
What Medical Professionals Are Required to Follow
Texas law ensures that licensed medical professionals and emergency responders follow valid directives. Hospitals, physicians, and EMS must honor properly executed living wills and DNRs.
However, they may decline to comply if the directive violates the provider’s ethical or religious beliefs. In such cases, they are required to transfer care to another provider who will comply.
Facilities must keep documentation on file and confirm the validity of your directives during hospital admission or treatment planning.
Planning Carefully with the Right Documents
Knowing the difference between a living will vs DNR can shape how your healthcare wishes are honored during a medical crisis. A living will sets the foundation for your long-term care preferences, while a DNR responds to immediate emergency situations.
By understanding what each one covers, when they apply, and how Texas law supports their use, you can create a more complete plan for your medical future. Speak with your healthcare agent, document your wishes clearly, and review your directives regularly.
Other Related Posts
- What Is a Special Needs Trust Fund and How It Protects Benefits
- Revocable Living Trust Tax Benefits: Essential Insights for Families
- Guardianship Application Process in Texas: Step-by-Step Legal Overview
- Special Needs Trust vs Supplemental Needs Trust: What’s the Real Difference?
- Should You Create a DIY Revocable Living Trust? What You Need to Know
- Understanding Adult Guardianship Requirements in Texas
- Advantages of a Revocable Living Trust: Why It May Be Right for You
- What Is the Purpose of a Living Will? Your Medical Wishes in Writing
- Understanding Medical Guardianship in Texas
- Revocable Living Trust Pros and Cons You Should Seriously Weigh
- How to Draft a Living Will Without Getting Overwhelmed: Texas Essentials
- Special Needs Trust Eligibility Requirements You Should Understand
FAQs: Living Will vs DNR
Yes. Many people have both to address different medical circumstances. They do not conflict with each other.
No. A living will alone won’t stop emergency responders from performing CPR. A DNR order is needed for that.
No. You can complete both documents without a lawyer. However, it’s wise to consult a healthcare provider to ensure everything is completed correctly.
Only if they can find and verify the Out-of-Hospital DNR form or bracelet. Without it, they are legally obligated to perform CPR.
You can revoke it at any time by notifying your doctor and destroying the document or removing identification tags. Make sure your medical record is updated accordingly.
