Can a 13-year-old choose which parent to live with?

Imagine a courtroom filled with tense anticipation. Divorcing parents on opposite sides, their hearts heavy with worry, awaiting the verdict that will shape their children’s lives. But amidst this sea of uncertainty, a young voice emerges, bold and determined. It’s their 13-year-old child, standing tall, ready to make a life-altering decision. Can you feel the tension? Can a 13-year-old actually decide who they want to live with? Buckle up, because we’re about to unravel the mysteries of teenage power in custody battles.

Short Answer: Yes, a 13-year-old’s voice can hold weight in custody decisions. But there’s more to the story than meets the eye, and that’s why you need to keep reading.

Reasons to Keep Reading:

Legal Insights: We’ll dive into the legal standards and criteria that judges consider when determining child custody, helping you understand the factors that shape the outcome of these battles.

Beyond Primary Conservatorship: While primary conservatorship is often the focus, we’ll explore various custody arrangements like joint custody, sole custody, and shared custody, shedding light on their implications for both parents and children.

Secrets of Resolution: Discover the power of mediation and alternative dispute resolution methods. These alternative paths can potentially lead to more cooperative and satisfying outcomes for everyone involved.

The Best Interests of the Child: Unravel the complex web of factors that judges weigh in determining the child’s best interests. Explore how age, parenting roles, communication, and even cultural considerations play a role in shaping custody decisions.

Navigating the Journey: From parenting plans to visitation schedules, we’ll guide you through the practical aspects that accompany custody battles, providing insights into creating stability and fostering positive co-parenting dynamics.

Factors Beyond Behavior: Learn about the impact of parental behavior on custody decisions, including substance abuse, domestic violence, mental health, and neglect, and how these factors are weighed by the courts.

Modifications and Flexibility: Understand the potential for modifying custody orders in the future and the circumstances under which such modifications can occur, ensuring you’re equipped with the knowledge needed to adapt to changing circumstances.

Expert Perspectives: Gain insights into the significance of psychological evaluations and expert testimony in custody cases, and how they contribute to the court’s understanding of the child’s well-being and the capacity of each parent to meet their needs.

Cultural Sensitivities: Delve into the importance of cultural and religious considerations in custody battles, as judges strive to preserve the child’s heritage and values within the custody arrangement.

Compliance and Enforcement: Discover the importance of compliance with custody orders and the potential consequences for non-compliance, ensuring a smooth and respectful co-parenting journey.

Custody battles can be emotionally charged, but understanding the nuances of the legal system and the factors at play can empower you to make informed decisions that prioritize your child’s well-being. Get ready to navigate the twists and turns of teenage power in custody battles and unlock the secrets to a brighter future for your family. Let’s dive in!

Of all the half-truths and misconceptions people have about child custody and divorce cases, probably the one that people seem to believe with the most significant amount of enthusiasm is the one where children of any age get to tell the judge who they want to live with- mom or dad. The judge would listen attentively and go along with the child’s wishes in naming one parent or the other as the primary conservator. I guess the case is over at that point, and everyone can go home.

The reality of the situation does not quite match the idea that many people have about how a divorce proceeds in a problem where both parents are attempting to be named as primary managing conservators. While I will certainly agree that this is a hotly contested issue in many family law cases, the truth of the matter is that it is not a given that your child will be able to talk to the judge about their wishes in terms of primary conservatorship. The other factor that we need to consider is whether the judge will care what your child would have to say if they go into the judge’s chambers to have a conversation.

What does a court do when it comes to listening to a child’s wishes?

The Texas Family Code states that a child twelve years old or older may speak to the judge about their preferences regarding their living situation after the family law case has come to an end. Either their mother or their father would be named as primary conservator. When you, your co-parent, or even the judge wants the child to share their thoughts with the judge, the judge must consider the child’s opinion to a certain degree. The meeting must occur so long as your child is twelve years of age or older.

Younger children may be able to have their opinions heard by the judge, but this is not a sure thing due to their age. The judge can consider a motion to have a judge come to speak to them, but the judge does not have to grant the action and have a conversation with your child. At that point, it is up to the court’s discretion as to whether the child should address the judge directly in private about their wishes as far as where they will live, primarily during the year.

What factors will a judge look to when determining child custody issues?

The whole point of going to court is to allow the judge to play a tiebreaker. Ostensibly, you and your spouse would not solve your problems together, so you must bring a judge into the equation to make decisions for you. This takes power out of your hands and places it in the hands of a person who does not know you and does not know your children. Nobody is better equipped than you and your spouse to make decisions on the living circumstances of your child. This is true even if the two of you are not necessarily seeing eye to eye on every subject under the sun.

If a judge does need to intercede into a question on which parent will become the primary conservator of your child, then you should be aware that several factors will be relevant. Every judge in Texas who hears family law cases has the authority to consider all, none, or something in between regarding these factors. On top of that, a judge will have the ability to put varying amounts of weight on each element based on their preferences. If this sounds a little disconcerting, then you are not alone. It is always a risk to place the fate of your case in the hands of a family court judge. Unfortunately, this can happen if you and your spouse/co-parent cannot agree before a trial.

The age of your children is the first factor that I believe judges consider when determining primary custody issues. Different children at different ages need other things from their parents. A younger child requires more moment-to-moment care than does a teenager. Teenagers require different types of care despite not needing it all the time. This is where a judge must also discern the relative strengths of you and your spouse when it comes to parenting to decide about which of you is better positioned to care for your children at this stage in their lives.

Fitting into this determination is how both you and your co-parent have taken part in raising your children to this point. Like it or not, a judge will essentially make decisions about determining the primary conservatorship of your children based on what roles you and your co-parent have filled to this point in their lives. For example, suppose you have been a stay-at-home parent who has prepared meals, taken the kids to ballgames, and tended to their every need. In that case, you will have an advantage in being named primary conservator if your spouse has been a traveling salesman who is away from home six days a week. That doesn’t mean your spouse is a bad parent. Instead, it means that a judge is not apt to rock the applecart and change conservatorship roles if they seemingly have been working out ok.

What you and your co-parent want to see happen as far as custody will also matter. A judge will not name you the primary conservator of your children if you do not wish to be placed in that role. It is a huge responsibility to be the primary conservator of children. Even if you would fill that role well in the eyes of a judge, they will not place you in that role unless you are asking for it. When a primary conservatorship is a contested issue, the judge will decide based on these factors. Otherwise, the judge will allow the parent who wants to be the primary conservator to fulfill that role unless it is not in the children’s best interests.

Communication is a huge issue when it comes to co-parenting. Making sure your co-parent is aware of all the relevant issues facing the children is essential for being the primary conservator. Being with the kids more throughout the week means that you will know what the kid’s homework schedule is like, if they haven’t been feeling well or if their soccer schedule has changed for this weekend’s games. If a judge has reason to believe that you will not take an active role in communicating those changes to your spouse, you will struggle to be named the primary conservator. This is true even if you otherwise would succeed in this role. Promoting your child’s relationship with their other parent is a big part of being a practical primary conservator of your child.

Related to this will be an analysis performed by the judge that goes to the issue of your relationship with your co-parent at the time of a trial. Judges can determine with quickness whether you and your co-parent can get along with one another. While the two of you don’t have to be best friends with one another, it is crucial to your child’s well-being that you be able to work together to solve problems that will inevitably confront them. If it seems like the two of you cannot get along at all, this will probably make the judge’s decision into primary conservatorship that much more difficult.

A more difficult decision for the judge to make is your child’s relationship with you and your co-parent. A judge will have to rely upon evidence at hand to decide about whose relationship is strong with the kids- yours or your co-parent. If your teenage child can speak to the judge, this should help him, or she decide which parent your child is closer with. Like all the other factors discussed in today’s blog post, this is not the only factor that a judge will consider, but it is essential, nonetheless.

If your child suffers from a mental or physical impairment of some sort, then the judge will consider that impairment, as well as which parent is better suited to care for your child in light of that impairment. The parent who has taken your children to more doctor appointments knows how to perform the primary care/maintenance for your child or can better calm your child down after an anxiety attack can position him or herself very well in becoming a primary conservator. Depending on the extent of these impairments, this issue may be critical to a family court judge.

If you have never taken care of the children on a primary basis, do not expect a judge to put you in that position after a family law case. The most important thing to a judge is the health and safety of your children. The health and safety of your children are best promoted by a parent who has taken on the role of primary conservator already. What I would not recommend doing is to file divorce and then suddenly transform yourself into Super Parent. Judges can tell when a parent has not fulfilled this role for most of a child’s life only to jump into that role immediately before a divorce. If you plan on asking to become the primary conservator of your child, then you should be ready to show that you have already done so with a great deal of success in your child’s life.

Who takes the kids to school each morning and makes sure that homework is each of their backpacks? Who knows how to give your children their medicine and adjust if need be? Who cooks meals? Who knows your kids’ friends and their parents? Who attends parent-teacher conferences with more significant regularity? These are questions that a judge will want to see the answer to before deciding about the primary conservatorship of your kids. Do not expect a judge to look favorably upon your case if you have never fulfilled these roles for your child.

The distance between your home and that of your co-parent is essential for naming conservators in a divorce or a child custody case. Many parents choose to live close together after a divorce or child custody case. This can make drop off-pick much more accessible and significantly reduce the stress associated with transition periods during the week. It also means that your child can attend the same school no matter where they live currently. If your child is integrated into their school community through athletics or other extracurriculars, but you plan to uproot him and send him to school across town where you plan on moving.

Another reason why living close to your co-parent is essential when it comes to being named the primary conservator of your children is that your work schedules play a role in this decision. Having a job with flexible hours or even a stay-at-home component will be in your favor since kids often have breaks from school or need to stay home for whatever reason. While there is nothing wrong with having a work schedule that is set in stone and difficult to deviate from, this is likely not going to be seen as a positive factor if you try to become the primary conservator of your children. Flexibility is key.

A big question that I receive from clients is whether it is an advantage for you to reside in the same house as the kids grew up in. The thinking is that if you can stay in the family home, you will have an advantage when it comes to being named the primary conservator. There is something to say for the consistency and stability that this kind of arrangement can offer, without a doubt. However, to say that simply staying in the same house as the kids grew up in will give you a leg up in this process may not be accurate. So many other factors will weigh on a judge that primary conservatorship rarely comes down to whether the kids can sleep in their same bedroom as they had growing up. That’s not to say that it isn’t essential at all, but these other factors are probably more meaningful, ultimately.

On the flip side of this discussion is the question of how much your children will need to adjust their lives to their changed living circumstances if you are named as primary conservator. Do your children need to change schools if you are named as primary conservator? What about extracurricular activities? Sports leagues? Friends? Church? These are the sort of considerations that a judge will need to consider strongly. While it is unreasonable to think that your child will not have to make any adjustments in the wake of your family case, it is just as little to think that they will have to change every aspect of their lives to accommodate you and your desires to become a primary conservator.

Finally, when a judge is asked to sit down with your child to discuss this topic with him, or she does not expect the judge to act as a therapist of some sort. You can expect the child to tell the judge about their basic preferences and their relationship with both you and your co-parent. The judge will try and play detective and work to understand more about your family because of the meeting. This factor will still be weighed with the other factors that the judge chooses to utilize.

Any negative behavior that is a part of your past will also be considered. Drug abuse, alcoholism, allowing people into the home that ought not to be there, mental health problems, and other issues will also be considered, along with the other factors discussed here today. Do not assume that just because you have a bit of a past as far as any of these subjects are concerned. You are treating them with doctor’s care, and taking responsibility for your actions matters a whole lot to a judge. Providing proof of your attendance in a twelve-step program can help you show a judge that you take these issues seriously and will place the interests of your children first and foremost in your life.

Questions about the material contained in today’s blog post? Contact the Law Office of Bryan Fagan

If you have any questions about the material contained in today’s blog post, please do not hesitate to contact the Law Office of Bryan Fagan. Our licensed family law attorneys offer free of charge consultations six days a week in person, over the phone, and via video. These consultations are a great way to learn more about the world of Texas family law and how your family’s circumstances may be impacted by the filing of a divorce or child custody case.

Legal Standards for Determining Child Custody

When it comes to child custody cases, there are specific legal standards and criteria that judges consider to determine the best arrangement for the child’s well-being. While the article briefly mentions the Texas Family Code and the age requirement for children to express their preferences, it doesn’t delve into the intricate details of these legal standards.

The legal standards vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, but common factors include the child’s best interests, the ability of each parent to provide a stable and nurturing environment, the child’s relationship with each parent, and the child’s age and maturity level. Judges carefully weigh these factors to make informed decisions regarding custody.

Types of Child Custody Arrangements

While the article primarily focuses on primary conservatorship, it’s important to note that there are various types of custody arrangements available. These include joint custody, sole custody, and shared custody. Each arrangement has its own implications and impact on the child’s upbringing and the involvement of both parents.

Joint custody involves both parents sharing the legal and physical custody of the child, with decisions regarding the child’s well-being made jointly. Sole custody grants one parent the primary custodial rights and responsibilities, while the other parent may have visitation rights. Shared custody involves the child spending significant time with both parents, usually in a 50/50 split.

Understanding these different custody arrangements provides a more comprehensive view of the options available to parents and the potential outcomes in custody cases.

Section: Types of Child Custody Arrangements

Custody Arrangement


Joint Custody

Both parents share legal and physical custody of the child, making joint decisions and sharing time.

Sole Custody

One parent has primary custodial rights and responsibilities, while the other may have visitation.

Shared Custody

The child spends significant time with both parents in a balanced, often 50/50, custody arrangement.

In this section, we explore different types of child custody arrangements to provide a comprehensive understanding of the options available to parents and the implications these arrangements have on both parents and children.

The Role of Mediation and Alternative Dispute Resolution

While the article mainly discusses the role of the judge in making custody decisions, it’s essential to consider alternative methods of resolving custody disputes. Mediation and alternative dispute resolution (ADR) can provide an opportunity for parents to reach a mutually agreeable custody arrangement outside of the courtroom.

Mediation involves a neutral third party who assists parents in negotiating and reaching a custody agreement. ADR methods, such as collaborative law or arbitration, offer alternative pathways for resolving disputes, focusing on cooperation and finding common ground.

Opting for mediation or ADR can be less adversarial and allow parents to have more control over the outcome, fostering a cooperative and amicable approach to determining child custody.

Best Interests of the Child Standard

Central to any custody decision is the principle of determining the child’s best interests. Although the article mentions that judges consider the child’s best interests, it doesn’t delve into what factors are typically evaluated or how judges determine what is truly in the child’s best interests.

Factors often considered include the child’s emotional and physical well-being, the quality of the parent-child relationship, the child’s developmental needs, the ability of each parent to provide a stable and supportive environment, the child’s educational and healthcare needs, and any history of abuse or neglect.

Understanding the best interests of the child standard is crucial for parents involved in custody cases, as it provides insight into what factors the court will consider when making decisions that impact their child’s future.

Parenting Plans and Visitation Schedules

Creating a comprehensive parenting plan and establishing visitation schedules are integral aspects of custody cases that significantly impact the practical arrangements for the child’s living situation and the involvement of both parents in their upbringing.

A parenting plan outlines how parents will share custody, make decisions regarding the child’s upbringing, and address important matters such as education, healthcare, and extracurricular activities. It ensures that both parents are on the same page and provides clarity and structure for the child’s well-being.

Visitation schedules, also known as parenting time schedules, determine when the noncustodial parent will have access to the child. These schedules specify regular visitation, holidays, vacations, and other important events. They aim to maintain a consistent and meaningful relationship between the child and the noncustodial parent.

Developing a well-thought-out parenting plan and establishing clear visitation schedules contribute to creating stability and promoting positive co-parenting dynamics.

Impact of Parental Behavior on Custody Decisions

The behavior of each parent can significantly influence custody decisions. While the article briefly mentions negative behavior and past issues, it doesn’t explore in detail how such behavior can impact custody determinations.

Factors such as substance abuse, domestic violence, mental health problems, or neglect can play a substantial role in custody decisions. Courts prioritize the safety and well-being of the child, and any behaviors that jeopardize the child’s welfare may negatively affect custody outcomes.

Demonstrating responsible and nurturing behavior, maintaining a safe environment, and actively engaging in the child’s life are crucial for both parents to secure favorable custody arrangements.

Modifications of Custody Orders

Custody orders are not always permanent. Circumstances may change over time, requiring modifications to the existing custody arrangement. While the article doesn’t explicitly mention this aspect, it is important for parents to understand the circumstances under which custody orders can be modified and the criteria for doing so.

Common reasons for seeking modifications include significant changes in the child’s needs, parental relocation, remarriage, changes in work schedules, or concerns about the child’s safety or well-being. Courts consider whether the requested modification is in the best interests of the child and evaluate the substantial change in circumstances to warrant a modification.

Parents seeking changes to custody orders should consult with their attorney to understand the legal requirements and process for seeking modifications.

Psychological Evaluations and Expert Testimony

In some custody cases, courts may employ psychological evaluations or expert testimony to assess the child’s well-being and the capacity of each parent to meet the child’s needs. While the article doesn’t touch upon this aspect, it is crucial to recognize the potential role of these evaluations and testimonies.

Psychological evaluations can provide valuable insights into the child’s emotional and psychological state, parental fitness, and the overall dynamics within the family. Expert testimony from professionals such as psychologists, social workers, or child development specialists can help the court make informed decisions regarding custody arrangements.

These assessments offer an objective and evidence-based perspective, aiding judges in determining the best custody arrangement for the child’s well-being.

Cultural and Religious Considerations

When determining custody, courts may take into account cultural or religious factors that are relevant to the child’s upbringing. The article doesn’t address this aspect, but it’s important to understand that in some cases, a child’s cultural or religious background may influence custody decisions.

Judges may consider how each parent can foster the child’s cultural or religious upbringing and maintain a sense of continuity in their lives. They strive to ensure that the child’s heritage and values are respected and nurtured within the custody arrangement.

Enforcement and Compliance with Custody Orders

Although not directly related to determining custody, it is important to consider the enforcement and compliance mechanisms for custody orders. Custody orders are legally binding, and both parents must adhere to the terms outlined in the order.

Understanding the consequences of non-compliance, such as contempt of court charges or potential modifications of custody orders, emphasizes the importance of following the court’s directives and ensuring that custody orders are respected.

Parents should prioritize the child’s well-being and maintain a cooperative approach to parenting, even in challenging situations, to promote a healthy co-parenting dynamic and compliance with custody orders.

In conclusion, understanding the legal standards, different custody arrangements, alternative dispute resolution methods, and other factors involved in child custody cases provides a comprehensive view of the complexities surrounding these proceedings. Custody determinations are intricate processes that prioritize the best interests of the child, and navigating them requires careful consideration of various factors, including the child’s well-being, the parents’ behavior, and the ability to create a stable and nurturing environment. Seeking legal guidance and understanding the nuances of custody cases empower parents to navigate these processes more effectively and promote the optimal outcomes for their children.

Phew! We’ve journeyed through the captivating realm of custody battles and teenage power, and now it’s time to wrap up our adventure. But before we bid adieu, let’s take a moment to reflect on what we’ve uncovered.

Picture this: A courtroom, once filled with tension, now transformed into a space of clarity and understanding. Parents armed with knowledge, navigating the legal landscape with confidence. A child, no longer a mere spectator, but an active participant in shaping their own destiny. It’s a sight to behold!

So, can a 13-year-old choose who they want to live with? The answer, my friend, is a resounding yes! But remember, the journey is never as straightforward as it seems. Legal standards, various custody arrangements, the power of mediation, the best interests of the child, and so much more swirl together to paint a vivid portrait of the custody battle landscape.

By unraveling these mysteries, we’ve empowered you to make informed decisions, champion your child’s well-being, and foster positive co-parenting dynamics. We’ve revealed the importance of cultural and religious sensitivities, compliance with custody orders, and the potential for modifications along the way.

So as you venture forth, armed with newfound knowledge, remember that you are not alone. Seek guidance from experienced professionals, lean on support networks, and approach this journey with an open mind and a resilient spirit.

Custody battles may have twists and turns, but you’ve got this! Keep advocating for your child’s happiness, prioritize their needs, and let love guide your decisions. Embrace the power of cooperation, compassion, and understanding. Together, you can create a future where your child thrives.

Now, my friend, go forth with confidence, armed with the knowledge and insights gained from our expedition. May your path be filled with brighter days, harmonious co-parenting, and a sense of fulfillment as you navigate the ever-evolving world of custody battles.

Remember, you’ve got the power. It’s time to create a story that defies the odds, a story where your child’s happiness takes center stage. Embrace this adventure, and let the journey begin!

Safe travels, courageous parent. The world of custody battles awaits, and you’re ready to conquer it.

Book an appointment with Law Office of Bryan Fagan using SetMore


undefined If you want to know more about what you can do, CLICK the button below to get your FREE E-book: “Child Custody E-Book”

Other Related Articles:

  1. The Truth About Child Custody Cases in Texas: Debunking 10 Common Myths
  2. What does a business owner need to know about child custody in Texas?
  3. Can cannabis use affect your parenting and custody rights?
  4. Managing High-Conflict Custody Cases in Texas: A Step-By-Step Guide
  5. Evaluating Parental Fitness: Home Studies and Custody Evaluations in Texas
  6. How grandparents can help themselves win custody of their grandchildren
  7. Police officers and child custody issues
  8. Do you have to pay child support if you have 50/50 custody in Texas?
  9. If you have primary custody (custodial parent), you can still be ordered to pay child support?
  10. The effect of substance abuse on child custody determinations
  11. In Texas, is it legal for my child’s mother to keep them from me?
  12. Can cannabis use affect your parenting and custody rights?
  13. Police officers and child custody issues
  14. What to do When Your Child Does Not Want to Visit the Other Parent
  15. If you have primary custody (custodial parent), you can still be ordered to pay child support?
  16. When Can a Minor Child Weigh in on Custody Decisions in Texas?
  17. Can an 11-year-old choose which parent to live with?

Frequently Asked Questions

Share this article



Related Articles

Contact Law Office of Bryan Fagan, PLLC Today!

At the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, PLLC, the firm wants to get to know your case before they commit to work with you. They offer all potential clients a no-obligation, free consultation where you can discuss your case under the client-attorney privilege. This means that everything you say will be kept private and the firm will respectfully advise you at no charge. You can learn more about Texas divorce law and get a good idea of how you want to proceed with your case.

Plan Your Visit

Office Hours

Mon-Fri: 8 AM – 6 PM Saturday: By Appointment Only

"(Required)" indicates required fields