Skip to content 
Criminal motions are powerful legal tools used by both the prosecution and defense to request specific actions or rulings from the court. These motions can significantly influence the direction and outcome of a case, whether it’s seeking to suppress evidence, dismiss charges, or compel testimony. Courts evaluate these requests at various stages—before trial, during proceedings, and even after a verdict—making them a vital component of the criminal justice process.
Attorneys use motions to address legal issues such as suppressing evidence, dismissing charges, or requesting a change of venue. Each motion requires legal arguments and supporting evidence. Judges often hold hearings to allow both sides to present their cases before making a ruling.
The decision on a motion can impact the direction of a trial, influencing whether evidence is admitted or charges are upheld. Understanding different types of motions helps both sides prepare their cases effectively.
Motion to Suppress Evidence
A motion to suppress evidence challenges the legality of how evidence was obtained. Defense attorneys file this motion when they believe law enforcement violated constitutional rights. Courts may exclude evidence obtained through illegal searches, coerced confessions, or warrantless seizures.
Key Reasons for Filing
- Law enforcement obtained evidence without a proper warrant.
- Officers conducted an illegal search or seizure.
- A confession resulted from coercion or a violation of Miranda rights.
To succeed, the defense must provide legal arguments and supporting evidence. The prosecution then presents counterarguments. Judges review both sides and determine if the evidence should remain part of the trial.
If a judge grants the motion, prosecutors may struggle to prove their case without the suppressed evidence. In some situations, charges may be dropped due to a lack of proof.
Motion to Dismiss Charges
A motion to dismiss seeks to end a case before it reaches trial. Either the defense or prosecution can file this request if legal issues prevent the case from moving forward.
Common Reasons for Dismissal
- Lack of Jurisdiction: The court does not have authority over the case.
- Insufficient Evidence: The prosecution lacks enough proof to support the charges.
- Double Jeopardy: The defendant has already been tried and acquitted for the same offense.
- Expired Statute of Limitations: The time limit for filing charges has passed.
Attorneys present arguments and evidence to support or oppose the dismissal. Judges evaluate both sides before making a decision. If granted, the case ends immediately. If denied, the trial continues as planned.
Motion for Discovery
A motion for discovery allows either party to request case-related information. The goal is to ensure fair access to evidence before trial.
Common Requests in Discovery
- Witness statements from police officers or informants.
- Police reports, lab results, and medical records.
- Expert testimony or forensic reports.
- Physical evidence collected during an investigation.
Defense attorneys or prosecutors must explain why they need the requested information. If the court grants the motion, the opposing party must provide the materials within a set timeframe. Failure to comply can result in penalties.
Discovery plays a crucial role in case preparation. Both sides must follow legal procedures to ensure all relevant evidence is available before trial.
Motion for Continuance
A motion for continuance requests a delay in court proceedings. Either party can file this motion if they need more time to prepare.
Reasons for Requesting a Continuance
- More time is needed to investigate or gather evidence.
- A key witness is unavailable on the scheduled date.
- The attorney or defendant has a medical emergency.
- Scheduling conflicts with the court, attorneys, or key participants.
The judge reviews the reasons for the delay before deciding. If granted, the court reschedules the trial or hearing. If denied, proceedings move forward as planned.
Courts consider a defendant’s right to a speedy trial when deciding on a continuance. Requests must be backed by valid legal arguments to receive approval.
Motion for Change of Venue
A motion for change of venue seeks to move a trial to a different location. Attorneys file this request if they believe a fair trial is impossible in the current jurisdiction.
Reasons for a Venue Change
- Extensive media coverage may have biased potential jurors.
- The defendant faces hostility or threats in the current location.
- The original venue is too far or inconvenient for key participants.
Attorneys present arguments and evidence supporting or opposing the change. If granted, the trial moves to a new jurisdiction. If denied, proceedings continue in the original location.
Courts carefully weigh the need for a fair trial against the logistical challenges of relocating a case.
Motion for Bail
A motion for bail requests the release of a defendant before trial. Judges consider several factors before deciding on bail conditions.
Factors That Affect Bail Decisions
- The defendant’s ties to the community, such as employment or family.
- Previous criminal history or lack thereof.
- The severity of the charges.
- The likelihood of the defendant fleeing or committing another crime.
Defense attorneys present arguments to justify release. Prosecutors may argue against it if they believe the defendant poses a risk. If granted, the court sets conditions such as travel restrictions or regular check-ins. If denied, the defendant remains in custody.
Bail decisions aim to balance public safety with the defendant’s right to freedom before trial.
Motion for Sentence Reduction
A motion for sentence reduction asks the court to lessen a defendant’s punishment. This request typically follows sentencing and relies on mitigating factors.
Common Reasons for Requesting a Sentence Reduction
- The defendant has shown good behavior or rehabilitation.
- Participation in programs such as drug or alcohol treatment.
- The defendant has provided assistance to law enforcement.
- The original sentence was excessive compared to similar cases.
Judges review arguments from both sides before making a ruling. If approved, the sentence may be reduced or modified. If denied, the original sentence remains.
Sentence reductions provide a second chance for those who demonstrate genuine reform.
Motion for Appeal
A motion for appeal challenges a trial court’s ruling. The defendant or prosecution can request a higher court to review the case for errors.
Grounds for an Appeal
- The trial court misinterpreted or misapplied the law.
- Evidence was improperly admitted or excluded.
- The judge abused discretion in sentencing or case rulings.
- The verdict was not supported by the evidence.
The appellate court reviews arguments and may allow oral presentations. After evaluation, the court can affirm, reverse, or modify the lower court’s decision.
The appeals process is complex and time-sensitive. Defendants must meet legal deadlines and present strong legal arguments to succeed.
Conclusion
Criminal motions serve as essential instruments in the legal process, offering both sides the opportunity to shape the course of a case strategically. Whether filed pre-trial to challenge evidence or post-trial to seek relief, these motions can dramatically affect the outcome. Understanding how and when to use them is critical for protecting legal rights and ensuring a fair trial.
Need Legal Assistance? Contact Us Today
Criminal charges require a strong defense strategy. The Law Office of Bryan Fagan is ready to help build your case and fight for the best possible outcome. Our legal team explains the criminal process and guides clients through each step.
If you or someone you know faces criminal charges, do not hesitate to reach out. We provide defense strategies designed to protect your rights and secure the best result.
We offer free consultations to discuss your case. Appointments are available through Zoom, Google Meet, email, or in-person meetings at your convenience.
Call us today at (281) 810-9760 to get started.
Other Related Articles
- Can You Be Arrested for What You Post? Social Media and Texas Criminal Law
- When Pranks Turn Criminal: The Fine Line Between Fun and Felony in Texas
- The ‘Texas Two-Step’ Defense: How Criminals Try to Game the Legal System
- Details on filing a motion for continuance in your divorce case
- What is a venue transfer?
- The Importance and Implications of Judicial Disqualification
- The Consequences of Drug Trafficking in Texas
- What Is Robbery In Texas
- What is the Statute of Limitations?
- Aggravated Assault In Texas
Criminal Motions FAQs
A criminal motion is a formal request made by a party involved in a criminal case to the court, asking for a specific action or decision on a particular matter in the case.
Common types of criminal motions include motions to dismiss, motions for discovery, motions to suppress evidence, motions for a change of venue, and motions for continuance.
In most cases, both the prosecution and the defense can file criminal motions. The specific rules and requirements for filing motions may vary depending on the jurisdiction and the stage of the criminal proceedings.
Criminal motions are typically decided by the judge presiding over the case. The judge will consider the arguments and evidence presented by the parties, as well as any applicable laws and legal precedents, in making a decision on the motion.
If a criminal motion is granted, it means that the court has agreed with the requesting party’s arguments and has taken the requested action. The specific consequences or outcomes after a motion is granted will depend on the nature of the motion and the stage of the criminal proceedings.
