Who Decides Alimony, A Judge or Jury?

Divorce often raises tough questions, and one that surprises many is: who decides alimony, a judge or a jury? Some assume a jury makes the call, while others believe there’s a strict formula courts follow. In truth, the answer depends on your state’s laws and the specifics of your case. In Texas, for example, a judge typically determines whether alimony is awarded, how much, and for how long. Knowing who decides alimony—and what factors influence that decision—can help you better prepare for the process and protect your financial future.

What Is Alimony?

Alimony, also called spousal support, is a court-ordered payment made by one spouse to the other during or after a divorce. It helps the receiving spouse maintain financial stability while adjusting to life after marriage. In Texas and many other states, alimony is not automatic. One spouse must ask the court for it, and the judge will decide based on certain conditions.

Alimony may be temporary or long-term. It can start during divorce proceedings and continue after the marriage officially ends. The purpose is to prevent one spouse from suffering unfair financial harm after the separation.

The Judge Has the Final Say

In most cases, a judge decides whether someone qualifies for alimony. The judge also decides the amount, frequency, and duration of payments. Unlike issues like fault in a criminal trial, alimony doesn’t involve a jury because it requires legal interpretation, not a finding of fact.

Texas law makes this clear. The court reviews the evidence, applies the rules, and issues a ruling. It’s a legal judgment, not a public opinion issue. That’s why only a judge handles it.

What the Judge Considers in Alimony Cases

The judge doesn’t pick a number at random. They evaluate a specific set of factors allowed under the law. The court looks at both parties’ financial situations and personal circumstances to make a decision that reflects fairness.

Common factors include:

Length of the marriage
Age and health of both spouses
Earning capacity and job history
Contributions to the household, including unpaid work
Education and training needs
Financial misconduct, such as hiding assets
Family violence or abuse during the marriage

Each of these factors carries different weight depending on the case. For example, a long marriage with one spouse who stayed home to raise children will look different than a short marriage between two working professionals.

What Happens in States With Jury Trials for Divorce?

Most states, including Texas, do not allow a jury to decide on alimony. A few states permit juries in divorce cases, but even then, they typically decide on fault or property division—not spousal support.

Texas allows juries in divorce trials, but only for limited parts of the case. These include things like who gets the house, who caused the breakup, or who gets custody. Judges still handle all issues related to support, including alimony.

So if you live in Texas, expect the judge to control all alimony decisions. A jury will not weigh in.

Can You Influence the Judge’s Decision?

Yes. Your actions during the divorce process matter. A judge looks closely at how both parties conduct themselves. If you fail to disclose financial documents or try to manipulate income, the judge will likely rule against you.

On the other hand, honesty, complete records, and respectful behavior often help your case. You can also provide supporting evidence, such as:

Tax returns
Pay stubs
Monthly expenses
Documentation of abuse or medical needs

This helps the judge see the full picture and decide fairly.

Temporary Alimony vs. Final Alimony

Divorce cases can drag on for months. One spouse may need support during the process. That’s where temporary alimony comes in. Judges can order it to keep things stable while the case moves forward.

Once the divorce is final, the judge may issue a new order for ongoing support. This may be lower, higher, or end entirely depending on the outcome of the trial.

How Long Does Alimony Last?

Judges set time limits based on the law. In Texas, the duration of spousal maintenance depends largely on how long the marriage lasted and the reason for the award.

For example:

5 years for marriages lasting 10–20 years
7 years for 20–30 years
10 years for over 30 years

Judges may also adjust the timeline if the receiving spouse has a disability or cares for a disabled child. These special circumstances can extend alimony beyond the typical limits.

Can Alimony Be Changed Later?

Yes. Either spouse can ask the court to modify the alimony order. This usually happens if something significant changes, such as:

One person loses a job
The paying spouse retires
The receiving spouse remarries
Health issues prevent continued payments

The judge reviews the new facts and decides whether to raise, lower, or end the support. Alimony doesn’t stay locked forever. Life changes, and the law allows adjustments.

What If Someone Refuses to Pay?

Once a judge signs an order, it becomes legally binding. If someone stops paying alimony without the court’s permission, the other person can take legal action. This might involve:

Wage garnishment
Contempt of court
Property liens
Jail time in extreme cases

The court takes unpaid support seriously. Skipping payments can bring harsh penalties.

Should You Settle or Let the Judge Decide?

Some couples reach an agreement on alimony outside of court. Mediation or negotiation may result in a plan both sides accept. This avoids trial and gives the couple more control.

But if no agreement happens, the judge makes the final call. In that case, both sides should prepare to present evidence and follow court rules.

Settling doesn’t mean giving in. It just means both people choose the terms. Once signed, a judge still needs to approve the agreement, but they usually accept fair arrangements.

What Your Lawyer Does in Alimony Disputes

A divorce lawyer plays a key role in alimony cases. They gather documents, build arguments, and represent you during hearings. They also help explain your legal rights and stop you from making avoidable mistakes.

Whether you expect to pay or receive support, a lawyer helps present your case clearly and with the right legal backing. That makes it easier for the judge to decide in your favor.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, understanding who decides alimony is essential when preparing for divorce proceedings. In most cases, including in Texas, judges—not juries—make the final call. The court evaluates key factors such as the length of the marriage, financial need, earning capacity, and contributions to the household before reaching a decision. The outcome depends heavily on the evidence presented and how effectively each party argues their case. Knowing that the judge holds this authority can help you approach alimony negotiations and courtroom appearances with greater clarity and confidence.

eBooks

If you want to know more about what you can do, CLICK the button below to get your FREE E-book:

Prepare for Divorce

13 Dirty Tricks

Divorce Related eBooks

FAQs

Can the amount and duration of alimony be negotiated?

Yes, the amount and duration of alimony can be negotiated between the spouses, either directly or with the assistance of their respective attorneys or mediators.

Is alimony always awarded in divorce cases?

Alimony is not automatically awarded in all divorce cases. Its determination depends on the specific circumstances and relevant laws of the jurisdiction.

Can alimony be waived?

In some cases, spouses may agree to waive their rights to alimony as part of a divorce settlement or separation agreement.

Can alimony be tax-deductible?

Alimony payments are tax-deductible for the paying spouse and taxable income for the recipient spouse, subject to certain conditions under applicable tax laws.