Skip to content 
Liberty County Fire Marshall Under Scrutiny
The case involving Liberty County Fire Marshal Bill Hergemueller and his deputies, Nat Holcomb and Jesse McGraw, has emerged as a significant scandal, drawing attention to widespread misconduct within a critical public safety institution.
In 2024, the Texas Rangers arrested the three officials after conducting a comprehensive investigation prompted by numerous complaints from local businesses and individuals. The charges brought against the trio, including official oppression, theft of property, and tampering with evidence, have raised serious questions about abuse of power and corruption within the Liberty County Fire Marshal’s Office.
At the heart of the allegations is the claim that Hergemueller and his deputies used their positions to engage in illegal activities for personal gain, including siphoning diesel fuel from crash scenes, stealing goods from wrecked vehicles, and coercing local towing companies into paying for unnecessary hazardous material services. The investigation revealed that none of the men held the proper certifications to perform fire inspections or investigations, making their actions not only unethical but also illegal.
Public Trust
The scandal has rocked public trust in Liberty County’s emergency services. Tasked with ensuring the community’s safety and enforcing fire codes, the Fire Marshal’s Office failed to uphold its duties. Instead, Hergemueller, Holcomb, and McGraw allegedly abused their positions to enrich themselves at the expense of the public and local businesses. As the legal process moves forward, this case will test the accountability of public officials in Liberty County and highlight the importance of ethical conduct in positions of authority.
The Investigation Into Them
The investigation against Bill Hergemueller, Nat Holcomb, and Jesse McGraw, which led to their arrests, began following complaints received by the Liberty County District Attorney’s office. District Attorney Jennifer Bergman disclosed during a press conference on September 25, 2024, that these complaints, along with concerns from multiple agencies and individuals, prompted the involvement of the Texas Rangers in January 2024.
As public servants, they conducted fire inspections, approved plans, and led fire investigations to protect public safety and uphold justice. However, the discovery that these officials had been manipulating evidence and falsifying records reveals a disturbing pattern of misconduct that casts doubt on the validity of numerous cases.
The investigation focused on allegations of theft, official oppression, and tampering with government records and evidence, as well as coercion of towing companies for payments linked to hazardous materials services.
Discovered Extortion From The Fire Marshall
The investigation uncovered that Hergemueller, the fire marshal, and Holcomb, a deputy fire marshal, used their positions to extort thousands of dollars from towing companies, leading to official oppression charges.
One towing company’s refusal to comply with these demands resulted in a retaliatory fire inspection, further implicating the defendants. Additionally, evidence surfaced of illegal activities at crash scenes, including siphoning diesel fuel and seizing goods such as fine cheeses and venison from an 18-wheeler involved in a collision. These actions, along with the removal of parts from another crash site, led to theft charges against the accused.
The Tampering Of Records
The investigation led by the Texas Rangers uncovered multiple instances where the three fire marshals altered or fabricated government documents and mishandled physical evidence.
Investigators found that Hergemueller, in particular, tampered with evidence from crash scenes by siphoning diesel fuel and taking goods from wrecked vehicles, all while presenting himself in his official capacity. Such actions not only violated legal standards but also compromised the integrity of the crime scenes. By tampering with or removing physical evidence, Hergemueller and Holcomb made it difficult, if not impossible, for investigators to conduct proper assessments of these incidents, which may have affected legal outcomes and accountability.
Fire Inspectors Were Not Licensed
Investigators discovered that all three men falsified fire inspection reports and conducted unauthorized inspections without proper state certifications. Lacking the necessary credentials, they performed inspections that were supposed to ensure the safety of businesses, schools, and other public institutions, rendering their actions effectively fraudulent. These falsified records not only put the public at risk but also allowed the officials to abuse their positions of power for personal gain, creating a scenario where local businesses felt coerced into compliance under false pretenses.
The tampering of government records in this context is particularly egregious because it strikes at the heart of public trust in government institutions, making it clear that the misuse of power within the Liberty County Fire Marshal’s Office was systemic and deliberate. As the case progresses, the tampering charges will likely play a pivotal role in determining the legal consequences for Hergemueller, Holcomb, and McGraw, while also prompting broader discussions about oversight and accountability in public service.
Throughout the investigation, the defendants admitted to their actions during questioning by the Texas Rangers. District Attorney Bergman expressed concerns about the potential impact these charges could have on other criminal cases. The full extent of the fallout from this case remains uncertain, but it has undoubtedly shaken public confidence in the Liberty County emergency services.
The Charges That They Face
The fire marshals, Bill Hergemueller, Nat Holcomb, and Jesse McGraw, from the Liberty County Fire Marshal’s Office, are facing an array of serious charges that stem from misconduct while performing their duties. The charges against these individuals highlight significant abuses of power, raising concerns about the integrity of public service in Liberty County.
Bill Faces Official Oppression, Theft And Tampering
Authorities have initially charged Bill Hergemueller, the fire marshal, with official oppression, theft of property, and tampering with physical evidence with intent to impair. Specifically, official oppression refers to the abuse of his position to coerce and intimidate others, notably by bullying towing service operators into paying him for hazmat services. Moreover, Hergemueller allegedly used his authority to convince these businesses that their continued operation depended on paying him thousands of dollars for unnecessary services.
In addition, authorities accuse him of stealing property from crash scenes, including siphoning diesel fuel from an 18-wheeler and taking food items like fine cheeses and venison. His tampering with evidence charge stems from his actions at these crash scenes, where he allegedly altered or removed physical evidence to conceal his misconduct.
Nat Faces Tampering With Government Records And Theft
Authorities charged Nat Holcomb, an assistant fire marshal, with tampering with government records and theft of property. Like Hergemueller, Holcomb participated in the illegal removal of goods and diesel fuel from crash sites. His tampering charge stems from falsifying documentation related to fire inspections and investigations, which the office conducted without the required state certifications. They used these unlawful inspections to extort businesses in Liberty County.
Jesse Also Faces Tampering With Government Records And Physical Evidence
Jesse McGraw, another assistant fire marshal, faces charges of tampering with government records and tampering with physical evidence. McGraw’s involvement in falsifying fire inspection records and participating in illegal actions at crime scenes underscores his role in the broader misconduct within the office. His tampering with evidence charge is tied to his participation in altering or removing evidence from crash sites.
The Arrest Of The Three Fire Marshalls
The arrest of Bill Hergemueller, Nat Holcomb, and Jesse McGraw could significantly impact the criminal cases they were involved in as fire marshals. As law enforcement officials overseeing fire investigations, conducting inspections, and gathering evidence from fire-related crime scenes, they played crucial roles in many cases. Now that authorities have arrested them on charges of tampering with evidence and government records, any case they handled may come into question, potentially undermining the legal process and affecting the outcomes of those cases.
Is The Evidence Still Credible
One of the most immediate concerns centers on the credibility of the evidence they handled. Consequently, if authorities find Hergemueller, Holcomb, or McGraw guilty of tampering with evidence in their roles, it casts doubt on the reliability of any evidence they collected or processed in previous cases. Defense attorneys representing individuals convicted based on evidence these officials handled may challenge those convictions, arguing that the evidence was improperly obtained or manipulated. This could trigger a series of appeals, retrials, or even case dismissals if investigators prove that critical evidence was compromised.
Their Inspections Can be Deemed Invalid
Moreover, their lack of proper certifications to perform fire inspections and investigations raises additional concerns. If they conducted inspections without proper authority, then any findings or reports they generated could be deemed invalid. This not only weakens the prosecution’s position in ongoing or concluded cases but also jeopardizes public safety, as it could mean that unsafe conditions in schools, businesses, or public institutions went undetected or unaddressed due to improper oversight.
Need Help? Call Us Now!
Do not forget that when you or anyone you know is facing a criminal charge, you have us, the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, by your side to help you build the best defense case for you. We will work and be in your best interest for you and we will obtain the best possible outcome that can benefit you.
Our team is here to explain your trial, guiding you through the criminal justice process with clarity and support every step of the way. If you’re navigating the complexities of criminal charges and the court system seems daunting, reach out.
Therefore, do not hesitate to call us if you find yourself or someone you know that is facing criminal charges unsure about the court system. We will work with you to give you the best type of defense that can help you solve your case. It is vital to have someone explain the result of the charge to you and guide you in the best possible way.
Here at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, our professional and knowledgeable criminal law attorneys build a defense case that suits your needs, aiming for the best possible outcome to benefit you.
At the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, we offer a free consultation at your convenience. You can schedule your appointment via Zoom, Google Meet, email, or in person. We provide comprehensive advice and information to help you achieve the best possible result in your case.
Call us now at (281) 810-9760.
Other Related Articles
Under The Freeway Flames: Unveiling The Hidden Arson Risks And How To Safeguard Our Cities
In the Heat of the Moment: Jamaal Bowman’s Fire Alarm Fiasco
The Texas Penalties for Tampering with Weapon Detectors
Understanding Tampering with Evidence
Liberty County Fire Marshal Case – FAQs
The main charges against Bill Hergemueller, Nat Holcomb, and Jesse McGraw include theft of property, official oppression, and tampering with evidence and government records. These charges stem from the officials’ alleged misconduct, such as stealing diesel fuel, goods from crash sites, and falsifying fire inspection records.
The three officials misused their positions by coercing towing companies into paying for unnecessary hazmat services, stealing from crash scenes, and conducting unauthorized fire inspections without proper certifications. They used their authority to further personal gain at the expense of public safety and trust.
Evidence tampering involved altering or removing physical evidence from crash sites. Hergemueller and Holcomb siphoned fuel from wrecked trucks and stole other items, while McGraw was also involved in falsifying government records related to fire inspections, further undermining the integrity of the investigations.
The unauthorized fire inspections conducted without proper licenses potentially endangered public safety. The inspections, which were supposed to ensure safety in public institutions like schools and businesses, were fraudulent, leading to potential risks going undetected.
This case has seriously damaged public trust in Liberty County’s emergency services. It revealed corruption and abuse of power by officials who were meant to protect public safety, raising concerns about the integrity of law enforcement and oversight in the county.
