Skip to content 
Last week, a dad told us he felt like he was starring in his own reality show called “Life Happens.” One minute, he was cruising along—work was steady, weekends with his kids were predictable, and even co-parenting had settled into a rhythm. Then life threw in a new job across town, a remarriage, and a house full of boxes. Suddenly, the old custody order didn’t fit his new reality. That’s where Texas Custody and Material and Substantial Change steps in.
At its core, this legal standard is what Texas courts use to decide if a custody order needs a tune-up when circumstances shift in a big way. The quick takeaway? If your life looks very different from when the original order was signed—and those changes affect your child’s stability—the court may allow a modification.
In this article, you’ll learn what actually counts as a “material and substantial change,” how parents in Texas have successfully navigated these tricky waters, and why judges sometimes say yes (or no) to custody modifications. Along the way, we’ll share practical strategies you can use right now, from smoothing transitions at home to understanding the evidence courts look for. You’ll also hear how The Law Office of Bryan Fagan, PLLC helps families like yours protect what matters most: your child’s future.
Key Takeaways
- A ‘material and substantial change’ in circumstances is required under Texas Family Code to modify custody orders, with documentation of significant changes being essential.
- The legal process for modifying custody involves filing a petition, presenting evidence of the change, and may be classified as uncontested or contested based on parental agreement.
- Prioritizing the child’s best interest is of utmost importance in custody decisions, guided by the Holley factors that assess the child’s emotional, physical needs, and overall welfare.
Your Family’s Future Starts Here
Don’t navigate your legal journey alone. Schedule a consultation now and get the clarity and support you deserve.
Defining “Material and Substantial Change” Under Texas Family Code
Under Texas Family Code Chapter 156, courts require proof of a material and substantial change in circumstances before modifying a custody order. This standard ensures that custody arrangements remain aligned with what serves the child’s best interest, rather than the convenience of either parent. A material and substantial change is not just a minor adjustment in family life—it must be significant, continuing, and directly tied to the child’s well-being. For a deeper exploration, see our resource on Texas Custody and Material and Substantial Change.
Documenting these changes thoroughly is essential when seeking a modification. Examples may include relocation that impacts school or visitation schedules, a substantial shift in a parent’s work hours, remarriage that alters household dynamics, or new medical or educational needs for the child. Courts look for credible evidence, such as employment records, school reports, or medical documentation, to determine whether the change rises to the level required under Texas law.
Because custody modifications directly impact a child’s stability, judges apply this standard carefully. The goal, consistent with Texas Family Code §153.002, is always the child’s best interest. Parents considering a modification should be prepared to show not only that life circumstances have changed, but also that altering the custody order will create a more stable, supportive, and nurturing environment for their child.
At the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, we guide families through this process with compassion and precision, ensuring that parents understand both the legal standards and the emotional realities at play. To learn more about related issues, explore our Texas Child Custody Resources, where we provide in-depth information to help you protect your child’s future.
Examples of Material and Substantial Change in Texas Custody Cases
Understanding what qualifies as a material and substantial change is critical when seeking to modify a custody order in Texas. Courts rely on this standard, found in Texas Family Code Chapter 156, to determine whether circumstances have shifted enough to justify a modification. A Texas Custody and Material and Substantial Change case must demonstrate not just temporary or minor adjustments in family life, but significant and lasting changes that directly affect the child’s best interests. For a deeper explanation, you can review our article, Does Your Custody Order Need to Be Modified?.
Common examples of qualifying changes include a parent’s relocation or repeated moves, which may disrupt the child’s stability and lead the court to impose geographic restrictions. A new residence that substantially increases the cost of travel for visitation can also meet this standard. Likewise, substantial changes in a parent’s employment—such as working overnight shifts, taking a job that requires frequent travel, or losing employment altogether—may qualify if they reduce the parent’s ability to provide consistent care.
Child safety is another central concern for Texas courts. Under Texas Family Code §153.002, the child’s best interest is the primary consideration in any custody determination. Evidence of family violence, abuse, neglect, or unsafe living conditions can weigh heavily in favor of modifying an existing order. Courts take these matters seriously, often acting swiftly to ensure a child is not exposed to dangerous environments.
Beyond safety, the child’s evolving needs also carry significant weight. For example, the onset of a medical condition requiring specialized care, behavioral or developmental concerns, or even academic struggles may warrant a custody change. Household changes, such as remarriage or the introduction of new siblings, can shift family dynamics enough to justify a modification, particularly if these changes affect the child’s emotional well-being or daily routine.
Each of these circumstances demonstrates how broad the concept of a material and substantial change can be, yet how carefully courts apply it to protect children. If you are considering whether your family’s situation qualifies, it’s important to seek guidance from an experienced attorney. The team at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan can help you evaluate your options, gather the right documentation, and present a strong case that prioritizes your child’s needs. For additional insights, visit our Texas Child Custody Resources.
Legal Process for Modifying Custody Orders in Texas
The legal process for modifying custody orders in Texas involves:
- Filing a petition with the court clerk’s office.
- Outlining the reasons for the requested modification in the petition.
- Providing evidence of a material and substantial change.
- Recognizing that both parents have the right to file for custody or visitation modifications.
Once the petition is filed, all parties listed in the current custody order must be notified of the proceedings. The modification request can be classified as uncontested if both parents agree on the changes or contested if there are disagreements. If the other parent does not respond or agree, the case becomes contested and requires a court hearing.
In cases where both parents agree on the proposed changes, an agreement must be drafted for the judge to sign. This agreement, once signed by the judge, must be filed to finalize the child custody orders modifying child custody orders. The court order has the authority to uphold, modify, or terminate the existing custody arrangement based on the evidence presented.
Providing valid reasons and credible evidence for the requested modification is crucial throughout this process. Whether the case is uncontested or contested, the final decision rests with the court, which the court considers will always prioritize the child’s best interests. In some cases, deferred adjudication may be an option.
Best Interest of the Child Standard
In any custody matter, Texas courts are guided by one unshakable principle: the child’s best interest. Under Texas Family Code §153.002, this standard ensures that custody decisions place the child’s safety, stability, and overall development above all else. When families face a Texas Custody and Material and Substantial Change, the court carefully evaluates whether a modification will truly enhance the child’s well-being. For a deeper look at how courts approach modifications, see our article, Texas Child Custody Order Modification: What You Need to Know.
Judges use the well-established Holley factors—first recognized by the Texas Supreme Court—to guide these decisions. These factors include the child’s wishes, their emotional and physical needs, potential dangers, each parent’s abilities, the stability of each home, and the parent’s capacity to support the child’s future. Courts may also weigh issues such as parental alienation, negative comments about the other parent, and the importance of maintaining sibling bonds.
Because life is always changing, courts remain flexible. The addition of a stepparent, the arrival of new siblings, or shifts in household routines can influence a child’s needs. Similarly, evolving circumstances—such as a child requiring additional emotional support or academic stability—can justify a custody modification. The goal is not simply to change an order for the sake of change, but to ensure that custody arrangements nurture the child’s emotional, physical, and psychological health.
Families navigating these issues often feel overwhelmed by the complexity of Texas law. That’s where the compassionate guidance of attorneys at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan makes a difference. Our team helps parents understand how courts evaluate best-interest factors, gather the right evidence, and present a compelling case. To learn more about how these legal standards work in practice, explore our Texas Child Custody Resources, where you’ll find practical insights tailored to parents across Texas.
Checklist for Parents Considering Custody Modification
Parents considering a custody modification in Texas should begin with a thoughtful and well-documented plan. Under Texas Family Code Chapter 156, a modification requires proof of a material and substantial change in circumstances that directly impacts the child’s best interest. Understanding what qualifies as such a change—and preparing the right evidence—is essential to presenting a strong case. For a deeper dive into this topic, see our article, Does Your Custody Order Need to Be Modified?.
Open and respectful communication with the other parent can often reduce conflict and may even result in agreed modifications, which are typically faster and less stressful than contested cases. However, when disagreements remain, careful documentation becomes critical. Parents should collect records such as employment changes that affect parenting time, medical reports demonstrating a child’s evolving health needs, school or daycare notes highlighting behavioral or academic concerns, and, when applicable, police reports or other official records that relate to safety issues.
It is also wise to keep track of changes in the child’s living environment or routines. Even small details—like changes in after-school care or challenges in transportation arrangements—can become important when courts consider whether the existing order still serves the child’s best interest. Courts give significant weight to consistency and stability, as reflected in Texas Family Code §153.002, which states that the best interest of the child is the primary consideration in custody matters.
Parents should avoid relying on informal, “handshake” agreements without court approval, since these are not enforceable and may complicate matters later. Acting promptly when significant changes arise not only helps protect the child but also prevents long-term disputes from escalating.
Working with a knowledgeable Texas family law attorney can provide clarity and peace of mind during this process. The attorneys at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan regularly help parents navigate the complexities of Texas Custody and Material and Substantial Change, guiding them step by step to ensure the child’s needs remain front and center. For additional insights on custody and related issues, you can explore our Texas Child Custody Resources.
Common Mistakes Parents Make in Custody Modification Cases
Parents navigating custody modifications in Texas should be mindful of common pitfalls that can jeopardize their case. Under Texas Family Code Chapter 156, courts will only grant a modification when there is clear and convincing evidence of a material and substantial change that directly impacts the child’s best interest. One of the most frequent mistakes parents make is failing to present sufficient proof of this change. Without compelling documentation—such as employment records, school reports, medical records, or testimony—courts are unlikely to approve a modification. For further guidance, review our article, How to Petition for a Modification After a Change of Circumstances in Texas Family Law.
Another critical error is overlooking the importance of the child’s best interests. Courts apply the standard found in Texas Family Code §153.002, which makes the child’s emotional, physical, and psychological well-being the primary concern. A modification request that centers on the parent’s convenience rather than the child’s stability will rarely succeed. Parents should focus their case on how the change will improve the child’s daily life, school performance, or overall safety.
Poor communication with the other parent is also a recurring problem. Constant conflict or failure to cooperate can disrupt the child’s routine and paint a negative picture in court. Judges often look favorably on parents who demonstrate a willingness to co-parent respectfully, even in difficult circumstances.
Social media is another overlooked hazard. Posts that disparage the other parent, showcase irresponsible behavior, or reveal inconsistencies can easily be introduced as evidence. Parents should exercise extreme caution online during a pending custody case.
Finally, waiting too long to act can have serious consequences. If a substantial change has occurred—such as a relocation, job loss, or a child’s new health needs—delaying a petition can undermine credibility and weaken the case. Acting promptly and with proper legal guidance gives parents the best chance of success.
The team at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan has extensive experience helping parents avoid these missteps. By focusing on Texas Custody and Material and Substantial Change and aligning every argument with the statutory standards, our attorneys provide both the strategy and support families need during challenging transitions. To learn more about related issues, visit our Texas Child Custody Resources, where we provide comprehensive insights to help parents protect their children’s futures.
How Bryan Fagan’s Attorneys Assist Families
At the Law Office of Bryan Fagan, our dedicated family law attorneys are committed to helping parents navigate the challenges of custody and support modifications with clarity and confidence. When families face a Texas Custody and Material and Substantial Change, our team provides the guidance necessary to secure arrangements that protect both parental rights and, most importantly, the well-being of children. Under Texas Family Code Chapter 156, a parent must demonstrate that a substantial and continuing change in circumstances has occurred before a court will consider modifying custody, visitation, or child support orders.
Children’s stability is at the heart of every case we handle. Whether the modification involves custody, visitation schedules, or financial support, our attorneys ensure that the child’s best interests—outlined clearly in Texas Family Code §153.002—remain the top priority. From parents seeking relief due to relocation or job changes to families adjusting to a child’s evolving medical or educational needs, our firm ensures that modifications are tailored to reflect each family’s unique circumstances.
We also recognize that custody changes often affect child support obligations. A custody shift may alter financial responsibilities, requiring a recalculation under the guidelines set out in Texas Family Code Chapter 154. Our attorneys help parents understand how these modifications impact both custody and financial support, ensuring no detail is overlooked. For more information, visit our Texas Child Support Resource.
The legal team at the Law Office of Bryan Fagan provides full-service representation throughout the modification process, preparing clients for hearings, helping them collect necessary evidence, and explaining how protective services or enforcement actions may factor into their case. We approach each matter with compassion and practical legal insight, empowering parents to make informed decisions that safeguard their family’s future. For additional resources on custody issues, explore our Texas Child Custody page.
Client Success Stories
Client success stories illustrate the profound impact of effective custody modifications. One client shared how a custody modification allowed their child to thrive in a more stable living environment, leading to significant improvements in their overall well-being. Another testimonial highlighted a child’s academic improvement and emotional well-being following a successful custody change.
These stories serve as powerful reminders of the importance of seeking modifications that align with children’s best interests. Common examples of prioritizing children’s needs allow parents to create a nurturing environment that supports their child’s well being and emotional development.
Importance of Legal Representation in Custody Modifications
Legal representation is essential for navigating custody modification cases. Pursuing a modification without a knowledgeable attorney in Texas poses significant risks due to the complicated issues and legal technicalities involved. Experienced family law attorneys ensure proper support, helping to build a strong case that prioritizes the child’s best interests.
Parents are strongly encouraged to schedule a consultation if they believe a material and substantial change justifies modifying their Texas child custody order, temporary order, or prior order visitation order. This proactive step can provide clarity and increase the chances of a successful outcome.
Internal and External Resources
Navigating custody modifications effectively requires access to a range of resources. Internal links to related topics such as custody modifications, child support changes, and enforcement can provide additional insights. External resources, including official Texas Office of the Attorney General resources, offer vital legal information.
Understanding the nuances of custody modification is crucial, and utilizing both internal and external resources can help parents make informed decisions. These resources provide comprehensive support, ensuring that parents are well-equipped to handle the complexities of custody modifications.
Conclusion:
Life rarely stays the same for long, and when big changes happen, your custody order may need to change too. The heart of the matter isn’t just paperwork or courtrooms—it’s making sure your child has the stability, support, and environment they need to thrive as your family grows and shifts. That’s why understanding how Texas courts view material and substantial change is so important.
If you’re reading this and thinking, “This sounds a lot like my life right now,” you’re not alone. Many parents face the same questions about what really counts as a significant change and how to show the court that it matters. The good news is that with the right guidance, you don’t have to figure it out on your own. An experienced Texas family law attorney can walk you through your options, explain how judges tend to look at these issues, and help you build a plan that protects your child’s best interests.
So here’s a thought to leave you with: life will keep changing, but with the right plan in place, your child doesn’t have to get lost in the shuffle. If you’re considering whether a custody modification makes sense for your family, reach out to The Law Office of Bryan Fagan, PLLC. We’re here to answer your questions, offer steady guidance, and help you take the next step toward a future where both you and your child can feel secure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes. Custody orders in Texas (legally called conservatorship, possession, and access orders) can be modified if there has been a material and substantial change in circumstances and the change is in the child’s best interest. Parents can agree on modifications, or the court will decide if they disagree.
A material change can include a parent’s relocation, a new work schedule, remarriage, unsafe conditions, family violence, or significant changes in a child’s needs such as health or schooling. The change must be substantial, not temporary, and directly tied to the child’s stability and best interests.
One of the biggest mistakes is focusing on attacking the other parent instead of proving how your plan serves the child’s best interest. Courts look for stability, cooperation, and credible evidence—like school records, medical notes, or calendars—not just accusations.
To request a modification, you must file a petition in the court that issued the original order. The petition explains the changes in circumstances and why the modification is in the child’s best interest. The other parent is served and may agree, or if they contest, the case can proceed through mediation or a hearing.
Not exactly. A child doesn’t get the final say, but children 12 or older may tell the judge their preference in chambers under Texas Family Code §153.009. The judge will consider the child’s wishes along with all other best-interest factors.
It depends on the custody order. Many orders include a geographic restriction that limits how far the custodial parent can move—often within a specific county or nearby counties. To move farther, the parent usually needs court approval or the other parent’s agreement.
Qualifying changes are substantial, lasting, and occurred after the original order. Examples include long-term job changes, relocation affecting parenting time, repeated violations of visitation schedules, or new health and safety issues affecting the child.
You must prove two things: (1) there has been a material and substantial change since the last order, and (2) modifying the order is in the child’s best interest. If you file within one year of the last order, stricter requirements apply—such as proving endangerment, voluntary relinquishment, or parental agreement.
Interference happens when a parent or another person intentionally prevents or disrupts the other parent’s court-ordered time with the child. This could mean refusing exchanges, sabotaging visits, or manipulating schedules. Interference can lead to enforcement actions, fines, extra visitation, and in some cases, even a change in custody.
